
A 1–0 home defeat to Everton left Newcastle 13th, Matthias Jaissle jeered on the lap of appreciation and a dropped sheet of paper carrying the argument. It also left a question that the manager’s own answers did not settle.
Eighty-seven minutes in, with rain slanting through the St James’ Park floodlights, Bazoumana Touré jogs onto the pitch holding a sheet of paper. Fabian Schär takes a quick look. Then he lets it drop.
The broadcast cameras find it on the wet turf: names in blue ink, Osula and Wissa across the top, Murphy and Steur lower down. Before the night is out, social media has spoken: the players, have stopped listening to Matthias Jaissle.
It is a neat story, maybe it’s true. The note was dumped on the pitch because the players don’t care anymore.
What the eye saw

Monday nights have been unkind to Newcastle for some time. They have lost 21 of their last 32 league games on the day, including both this season, 4–1 to Leeds and 4–1 to Coventry. This one starts promisingly enough, then drifts into the worst first half they have produced all season. The ball goes long, again and again, towards William Osula, who has touched it five times by the half-hour. Barely a quarter of those long balls find a team-mate. There is no pattern to the play, no obvious idea about who should be where, and no tempo until Everton choose to supply it. Thierno Barry, Everton’s French striker, spurns one clear chance and Harrison Armstrong, a young Everton midfielder, shoots wide with the goal at his mercy. The score at the break is 0–0 only because Everton are generous. The boos at the whistle come from a minority. They will not stay a minority for long.
The second half is better, though not by much. Elanga’s touch at the back post spins off Jordan Pickford and the upright and along the goal line. Jacob Ramsey drives a clean strike inches past the post. But Newcastle’s first shot on target, a tame 25-yarder from Yoane Wissa, does not arrive until the 85th minute.
By then they are behind, and the goal is the sort that hurts. Everton take a quick free kick after Joelinton and Barry tangle in Newcastle’s half. James Garner plays it short, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall feeds Tyrique George, and George’s shot goes straight at Lukas Hornicek. It squirms beneath the goalkeeper, and Barry taps into an empty net. Newcastle appeal for a foul on Schär in the build-up and for offside. VAR takes its time and gives neither.
It is another error leading to a goal. Newcastle’s count of those had reached four by the hour on Opta’s numbers, bettered only by Sunderland and Hull, and this one belonged to the goalkeeper. Hornicek makes several good saves afterwards, but the damage is done and the home crowd knows it.
The Note
Touré replaces Amar Dedić at 87 minutes and carries the sheet on. Players arriving with a note from the bench is a familiar sight, a way of passing a change of shape through the noise without shouting. What Schär did with this one has been read as contempt. I cannot see inside his head, no one can. Dropping a note after reading it is as consistent with a player who has absorbed it as with one who has ignored it.
It could be a symptom or it could be nothing, and the truth is that nobody outside the dressing room knows which. The evidence on Schär is mixed. FotMob rates him Newcastle’s best outfield player on the night, and he is booked in the scuffle at the end. But on a night when the manager himself says the plan was not followed, a centre-half dropping a team sheet on the turf is not a picture anyone at the club will have wanted.
Touré’s three minutes on the pitch do produce the best move of the night. Barnes finds him down the left, he reaches the byline and pulls it back, and Pickford saves Wissa’s shot with his right boot. Moments later Ramsey is sent off for two yellow cards in the space of two minutes, the second for catching Armstrong’s ankle. The final whistle brings the loudest booing of the evening.

A manager on the defensive
In the press room, Jaissle sounds defensive. He knew the questions would be hard, and he answers them by spreading the weight around.
He talks about a week of good training that did not make it onto the pitch. He says the plan was to press high at home and to build through patterns, and that his side were “not brave enough in possession”. He is blunt about the long balls: “Long balls was not the plan.” He says the goal should have been disallowed for a foul on Schär. He accepts the unforced error that led to the free kick, says the team was “just sleeping”, and allows that on a better day the goalkeeper saves George’s shot. And in among it all he says: “I am responsible for that.”
The ownership is there, but it arrives in general terms, while the specifics he offers point at the pitch and the officials. That produces the conflict in the coverage. Some of the next-morning headlines have him blaming the players for ignoring his instructions. Others stress that he took responsibility, and the recording supports both readings. If the long balls were not the plan, then either the players did not carry out the plan or the plan was not clear enough to survive the first bad ten minutes. The note may be a symptom of that disagreement, and it may just be a piece of paper.
What it means
The lack of confidence is the issue here, and the pattern behind it is easy to see. Newcastle have conceded in all five home league games this season and have gone 14 straight home league games without a clean sheet, the longest run in the club’s league history. A side braced for the next mistake will often play it long to avoid its own half. That is a fixable habit, and Jaissle is nine league games into a new job with a squad that has changed a great deal since the summer.
He indicated he will not tear up the team after one bad night, because players need to feel one poor performance will not cost them their place. He also left a door open: anyone pushing hard in training makes the choice easier, and Sean Steur, who made an encouraging cameo, is clearly in his thinking.
The next test is Fulham away on Saturday at 3pm, the last match before the international break. Ramsey’s red brings an automatic one-match suspension. After the break comes Arsenal at St James’ Park on 21 November, the league leaders fresh from a 1–0 win at Anfield, and then Brighton away on 29 November, a side sitting third on 19 points. The table still gives Newcastle some room: they are on 11 points, four clear of 18th. The fixtures give them very little.
Everton, up to seventh on 13 points, have their first away league win of the season, and David Moyes’s side now turn to Coventry.
On Saturday at Craven Cottage, a new sheet will be written, handed across and read. Plenty of people will be watching to see what Schär does with it.

Leave a Reply