Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Squad

  • Jaissle Walks Into Craven Cottage With the Boos Still Ringing

    Fulham v Newcastle Match Poster

    Four defeats in five, a restless home crowd and a first meeting with Álvaro Arbeloa’s Fulham: Newcastle’s head coach has 90 minutes in west London to change the mood before the international break.

    Fulham captain Tom Cairney’s left foot found the top corner at Craven Cottage in the 80th minute of last season’s final day, and two managers with uncertain futures watched it go in. Marco Silva beat Eddie Howe 2-0 that afternoon, Fulham taking 21 shots to Newcastle’s seven. By the summer both men had gone.

    Their successors meet at 3pm tomorrow, at a ground tucked between the Thames and Bishop’s Park, and so far as I can establish they have never faced each other before. Matthias Jaissle, 38, arrives 13th in the table with the sound of Monday night’s boos still in his ears. Álvaro Arbeloa, 43, came to Fulham after five months in the Real Madrid dugout, went six league games without a win and heard the sack talk before three unbeaten matches steadied the room. Both need the points. The break that follows will either settle a dressing room or hand the doubters a fortnight.

    The night it came apart

    Four minutes after half-time on Monday, Everton’s Tyrique George struck a shot that reached Lukáš Horníček at a comfortable height. It squirmed under the goalkeeper’s body and striker Thierno Barry tapped into an empty net. St James’ Park, already booing at the interval, did not need the replay. Newcastle’s first shot on target, from Yoane Wissa, arrived in the 86th minute. Jacob Ramsey, on as a late substitute, collected two bookings inside a minute and a half and walked.

    Jaissle told the supporters to blame him. His reign had opened with an unbeaten run of 2-2 against Liverpool, 2-0 at Tottenham and 2-2 at Bournemouth. Then came Elland Road, where Leeds striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin ran the evening, a 4-1 hammering at Coventry and a 1-0 loss to Aston Villa. A 2-0 win at Crystal Palace was followed by a 3-1 Carabao Cup defeat at Everton, and then Monday.

    TeamTalk has reported that players are struggling to adjust to his methods, and newspapers are already running lists of available replacements. Jaissle says his job is not on his mind.

    His squad also did not exist in July. Tonali (£100m to Tottenham), Guimarães (£75m to Arsenal) and Gordon (£69.3m to Barcelona) left for more than £240m between them, while eight first-team signings worth roughly £265m arrived between mid-June and deadline day. Those fees buy a great deal of talent and very little familiarity, and a midfield assembled that way has had to learn itself in public.

    What has to change

    Jaissle says he adjusts his principles to the opposition. Tomorrow tests that, and my view is that the No.10 has to go. He has leaned on a 4-2-3-1 with no specialist in the role, and Everton walked through the middle of it. Only Palace have faced more shots than Newcastle’s 154.

    I would move to a 4-3-3 with Nico González, the £47m arrival from Manchester City, at the base and Sean Steur and Joe Willock ahead of him, with Lewis Miley in if his knock has cleared. Harvey Barnes and Anthony Elanga are tireless on the flanks, Lewis Hall gives the left side a settled base, and a team that forces opponents wide defends better. That was the logic of Howe’s 4-3-3, though it leaned on Bruno Guimarães, Sandro Tonali and Joelinton. Bruno and Sandro have left, and this gives their replacements a chance to prove themselves.

    The right flank is the awkward part. Tino Livramento is out long term, which leaves Amar Dedić as the only fit senior right-back. The BBC gave him a 4 on Monday, and his poor clearance began Everton’s first goal in the cup. He needs protection from the eight in front of him.

    Further back I would drop Fabian Schär, 34 and short of the recovery pace Everton’s counters demanded, and bring in Malick Thiaw. Dan Burn stays. At 201cm he and the 194cm Thiaw suit a Fulham side that has won 56 corners, second only to Tottenham. Horníček also stays. He was man of the match at Palace a week before Monday, and dropping him after one error would tell a nervous dressing room that nobody is safe. Most predicted line-ups keep Horníček, Schär and Burn, so the outside world expects Jaissle to stand firm.

    The hosts

    Arbeloa’s Fulham score sparingly. Their nine goals are fewer than all but Nottingham Forest and Sunderland, and they have scored exactly once in each of their last five league games. They have conceded one in the last three. Goalkeeper Bernd Leno sits behind a back four built around centre-halves Calvin Bassey and David Affengruber, with midfielders Sander Berge and Shea Charles screening them and Joshua King in the No.10 slot. Striker Gonzalo Garcia, who arrived from Real Madrid, has gone eight league starts without a goal, and Ryan Sessegnon, the left-sided defender, is back from a three-match ban for a red card against Hull.

    The history favours them. Fulham have won three of the last four league meetings, the latest through Cairney’s strike and a header from centre-half Issa Diop. The exception came last October, when Guimarães took a loose ball and scored at the Gallowgate End in the 90th minute for a 2-1 win. He now plays for Arsenal, who visit St James’ Park after the break. None of the 18 league meetings between these clubs in London has ended in a draw. Perhaps now is the best time for one. Neither team will want a draw, which probably makes it the best result, and it steadies the Newcastle ship somewhat after a series of disappointments in recent weeks.

    Pressing to impress

    Steur is 18, cost £19.6m from Ajax and has a growing band of supporters demanding he start. Will Osula, 23, the Danish striker, combined with Barnes at Palace and leads the line. Joelinton and Ramsey are out. Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the £51m forward from Lille, is training again after more than two weeks with a virus and should be on the bench.

    Predicted XI (4-3-3): Horníček; Dedić, Thiaw, Burn, Hall; González, Steur, Willock; Barnes, Osula, Elanga.

    Prediction

    Fulham 1-1 Newcastle. Fulham have been scoring one at a time, and Newcastle took 17 shots at Everton and had nothing to show for them. The record says someone wins in London, and I am picking the draw anyway.

    A point sends Jaissle into the break with a fortnight to find a plan before Arsenal arrive at St James’ Park. A win would send him there to cheers.

  • The Second Match

    Five defeats in seven, a restless St James’ Park and a timeline full of verdicts. On what the noise around Matthias Jaissle does to those of us listening.

    Five defeats in seven matches, thirteenth in the table, and a St James’ Park that vented its anger at half-time on Monday night and again at the final whistle. Everton had already won in the Carabao Cup, away from home. Now they had won again on Tyneside, in the league, and the frustration came down off the stands in waves.

    Then the match on the pitch ended and a second one began, the argument over what it all meant, fought out online.

    The second match is played on phones. Its pitch is a timeline, a Reddit thread, a WhatsApp group that has been silent since the weekend and suddenly lights up with twelve messages in a minute. It has no referee and no final whistle. After the Aston Villa defeat earlier this season, supporters of Al-Ahli, the Saudi club Jaissle managed before he came to Newcastle, had a hashtag demanding his sacking running within minutes. People with no season ticket and no stake in where Newcastle finish joined the chorus, and nobody scrolling past could tell which voices belonged to the Gallowgate and which belonged to somewhere else entirely.

    I have no verdict to add on Jaissle here. I’ll leave that argument to others for now. What interests me is what the volume does to the rest of us while we listen.

    The pull

    In 1951, Solomon Asch put a young man in a room at Swarthmore College with seven other people and a card showing a line. The task was to say which of three other lines matched it. The answer was obvious. The other seven, all of them actors, had been told to give the same wrong answer on twelve of the eighteen rounds.

    About a third of the answers on those critical rounds matched the planted majority. Three-quarters of the participants went along with the room at least once. In a control group with no actors, fewer than one per cent of people got it wrong.

    Asch also found the thread that unravels the whole thing. When a single actor broke ranks and gave the right answer, conformity dropped sharply. One dissenting voice made the other seven far easier to resist.

    Asch’s lines had a correct answer printed on the back of the card. Football offers nothing of the kind. Is Matias Fernandez-Pardo ready to start? Does a particular system suit this particular squad? Is a manager two months into the job showing flaws or still finding his feet? Those questions have no card with the answer on the back, which makes the room even more persuasive.

    I’ll put my hand up. When I see a wall of people asking for something, whether it’s a manager sacked or a £51m forward in the starting eleven, it builds a sense of expectation. Often I catch myself agreeing because I want to belong to the right group. If the masses say it, part of me wants to be among the masses. When the subject is something I care about this much, the pressure is intense.

    It works the same way with politics and religion. Football just happens to be a small, niche, constantly observable laboratory for it, and Newcastle, with its fifty-two thousand voices and its permanent state of heightened feeling, is a very good place to watch it happen.

    A price is not a fact

    Bankers know this pattern in another costume.

    In 1983, Douglas Diamond and Philip Dybvig published a model of a bank run. Their point was uncomfortable. A perfectly solvent bank can fail if enough depositors believe other depositors are about to withdraw. Each individual’s decision is rational given what they expect everyone else to do. Nobody needs to have read the balance sheet. The belief about other people’s belief does the damage.

    A campaign to sack a manager, Jaissle now or anyone else in future, has the same architecture. The more people who say it, the more it seems that others must have seen something, and the more reasonable it feels to say it too. A share price works this way as well. It records what the market is willing to pay today, and whether the company is worth that is a separate question that someone has to answer by doing the work.

    The temperature of a timeline is a price. It tells you what the crowd is willing to say right now, which is useful information about the crowd.

    Who is actually talking

    A Pew Research Center study of American adults on Twitter, published in 2019, found that the most active ten per cent of users produced about eighty per cent of the tweets. The median user posted twice a month. Nothing in that study was about football, the platform has changed since, and the data is American. It still describes how a timeline gets its shape: a small, prolific minority generating most of the words, and a much larger audience that reads and says nothing.

    From where I sit, loud and numerous look identical. A thousand angry posts in an hour feel like a thousand angry supporters. Some of them are one supporter posting eleven times.

    Framing adds another layer. Several outlets this week ran headlines built around the word “sack”. Read beneath them and the reports describe a club with no plans to move, a board said to be standing by its man. I can’t see inside the building and those are reports, not facts, but the gap between the headline and the copy tells you something about how a story gets its temperature. The word that goes into the headline is the word that goes into the group chat.

    The best outcome and the likeliest one

    Thinking independently takes deliberate effort. It needs quiet time, away from the notifications, to sit with an issue and let it settle. Then comes a second job that I find harder: separating what would be the best outcome from what is the most likely one. They are sometimes mutually exclusive.

    A change in the dugout might be the best thing for the club and also the least likely to happen. A change might be the likeliest outcome and also a poor idea. A signing might deserve a start on merit and still sit on the bench for reasons nobody outside the training ground can see. The crowd tends to fuse these questions into a single demand, because a demand is easier to type than a probability.

    Inside a bank’s credit committee, nobody asks which outcome the room would like. They ask which outcome the file supports, and how confident anyone should be. It feels cold at first. It is also the only way I know to keep wishing and forecasting apart.

    The phrasing matters

    This is one of the things I think hardest about when I write for this blog. “Under pressure” and “failing” are different sentences. “Calls for” and “demands” are different sentences. A choice of verb can carry a conclusion into a reader’s head before the evidence has arrived, and I would rather the reader reach their own conclusion on the way. If I do my job properly, you finish a post of mine knowing what happened, why it might have happened, and where I am uncertain, with room left to disagree with me.

    Newcastle travel to Craven Cottage on Saturday to face Fulham. Before a ball is kicked, someone in the group chat will already have decided what the result is going to mean, win or lose. I’d like to watch the match first and make up my own mind afterwards.

  • The Note on the Grass

    Newcastle vs Everton Match Report

    A 1–0 home defeat to Everton left Newcastle 13th, Matthias Jaissle jeered on the lap of appreciation and a dropped sheet of paper carrying the argument. It also left a question that the manager’s own answers did not settle.

    Eighty-seven minutes in, with rain slanting through the St James’ Park floodlights, Bazoumana Touré jogs onto the pitch holding a sheet of paper. Fabian Schär takes a quick look. Then he lets it drop.

    The broadcast cameras find it on the wet turf: names in blue ink, Osula and Wissa across the top, Murphy and Steur lower down. Before the night is out, social media has spoken: the players, have stopped listening to Matthias Jaissle.

    It is a neat story, maybe it’s true. The note was dumped on the pitch because the players don’t care anymore.

    What the eye saw

    Monday nights have been unkind to Newcastle for some time. They have lost 21 of their last 32 league games on the day, including both this season, 4–1 to Leeds and 4–1 to Coventry. This one starts promisingly enough, then drifts into the worst first half they have produced all season. The ball goes long, again and again, towards William Osula, who has touched it five times by the half-hour. Barely a quarter of those long balls find a team-mate. There is no pattern to the play, no obvious idea about who should be where, and no tempo until Everton choose to supply it. Thierno Barry, Everton’s French striker, spurns one clear chance and Harrison Armstrong, a young Everton midfielder, shoots wide with the goal at his mercy. The score at the break is 0–0 only because Everton are generous. The boos at the whistle come from a minority. They will not stay a minority for long.

    The second half is better, though not by much. Elanga’s touch at the back post spins off Jordan Pickford and the upright and along the goal line. Jacob Ramsey drives a clean strike inches past the post. But Newcastle’s first shot on target, a tame 25-yarder from Yoane Wissa, does not arrive until the 85th minute.

    By then they are behind, and the goal is the sort that hurts. Everton take a quick free kick after Joelinton and Barry tangle in Newcastle’s half. James Garner plays it short, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall feeds Tyrique George, and George’s shot goes straight at Lukas Hornicek. It squirms beneath the goalkeeper, and Barry taps into an empty net. Newcastle appeal for a foul on Schär in the build-up and for offside. VAR takes its time and gives neither.

    It is another error leading to a goal. Newcastle’s count of those had reached four by the hour on Opta’s numbers, bettered only by Sunderland and Hull, and this one belonged to the goalkeeper. Hornicek makes several good saves afterwards, but the damage is done and the home crowd knows it.

    The Note

    Touré replaces Amar Dedić at 87 minutes and carries the sheet on. Players arriving with a note from the bench is a familiar sight, a way of passing a change of shape through the noise without shouting. What Schär did with this one has been read as contempt. I cannot see inside his head, no one can. Dropping a note after reading it is as consistent with a player who has absorbed it as with one who has ignored it.

    It could be a symptom or it could be nothing, and the truth is that nobody outside the dressing room knows which. The evidence on Schär is mixed. FotMob rates him Newcastle’s best outfield player on the night, and he is booked in the scuffle at the end. But on a night when the manager himself says the plan was not followed, a centre-half dropping a team sheet on the turf is not a picture anyone at the club will have wanted.

    Touré’s three minutes on the pitch do produce the best move of the night. Barnes finds him down the left, he reaches the byline and pulls it back, and Pickford saves Wissa’s shot with his right boot. Moments later Ramsey is sent off for two yellow cards in the space of two minutes, the second for catching Armstrong’s ankle. The final whistle brings the loudest booing of the evening.

    A manager on the defensive

    In the press room, Jaissle sounds defensive. He knew the questions would be hard, and he answers them by spreading the weight around.

    He talks about a week of good training that did not make it onto the pitch. He says the plan was to press high at home and to build through patterns, and that his side were “not brave enough in possession”. He is blunt about the long balls: “Long balls was not the plan.” He says the goal should have been disallowed for a foul on Schär. He accepts the unforced error that led to the free kick, says the team was “just sleeping”, and allows that on a better day the goalkeeper saves George’s shot. And in among it all he says: “I am responsible for that.”

    The ownership is there, but it arrives in general terms, while the specifics he offers point at the pitch and the officials. That produces the conflict in the coverage. Some of the next-morning headlines have him blaming the players for ignoring his instructions. Others stress that he took responsibility, and the recording supports both readings. If the long balls were not the plan, then either the players did not carry out the plan or the plan was not clear enough to survive the first bad ten minutes. The note may be a symptom of that disagreement, and it may just be a piece of paper.

    What it means

    The lack of confidence is the issue here, and the pattern behind it is easy to see. Newcastle have conceded in all five home league games this season and have gone 14 straight home league games without a clean sheet, the longest run in the club’s league history. A side braced for the next mistake will often play it long to avoid its own half. That is a fixable habit, and Jaissle is nine league games into a new job with a squad that has changed a great deal since the summer.

    He indicated he will not tear up the team after one bad night, because players need to feel one poor performance will not cost them their place. He also left a door open: anyone pushing hard in training makes the choice easier, and Sean Steur, who made an encouraging cameo, is clearly in his thinking.

    The next test is Fulham away on Saturday at 3pm, the last match before the international break. Ramsey’s red brings an automatic one-match suspension. After the break comes Arsenal at St James’ Park on 21 November, the league leaders fresh from a 1–0 win at Anfield, and then Brighton away on 29 November, a side sitting third on 19 points. The table still gives Newcastle some room: they are on 11 points, four clear of 18th. The fixtures give them very little.

    Everton, up to seventh on 13 points, have their first away league win of the season, and David Moyes’s side now turn to Coventry.

    On Saturday at Craven Cottage, a new sheet will be written, handed across and read. Plenty of people will be watching to see what Schär does with it.

  • Ten seconds at the touchline: Dedić, Moyes and the rookie’s lesson

    Newcastle v Everton

    Amar Dedić played under Matthias Jaissle long before Tyneside, and still gifted Everton two goals on Thursday. On Monday the pair of them face David Moyes again, and both have a point to prove.

    Thirty-four minutes into the Carabao Cup tie at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, Jordan Pickford, Everton’s England goalkeeper, hits a long kick forward. Tyrique George, a young Everton winger, closes down Amar Dedić near the touchline, and Newcastle’s right-back has a choice. He can put the ball into the stand. He tries to play his way out.

    Hayden Hackney, a holding midfielder signed from Middlesbrough in the summer, collects the loose ball and slides it to James Garner, who drives into the box and bends a shot into the far corner. It is 1-0. Jaissle will call it a “no-risk zone” afterwards, a patch of pitch where the only sensible answer is to clear the ball.

    Thirty-five minutes later it happens again. Newcastle are 2-0 down and chasing, the ball runs loose in their own half, and Garner leads a break that ends with Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Everton’s attacking midfielder, running in behind Dedić. Dedić cannot catch him or stay close to him. Dewsbury-Hall pulls the ball back, and Thierno Barry, Everton’s French striker, needs one touch to sweep it into the top corner.

    Two goals, one right-back, and no brilliance required from the opposition. Dedić was not alone on the night. As I wrote on Friday, Dan Burn and Jacob Ramsey share the blame for Hackney’s goal just before half-time. But Dedić’s two carry a different weight.

    Nobody in the squad knows what Jaissle wants better than he does. He played for him at Liefering and then at Salzburg, he was the first signing of the Jaissle era, and Newcastle paid about £30m to bring him from Benfica in August. The day he signed, Jaissle called him “incredibly hungry to prove himself” in the Premier League. In his first four matches he had three assists, two against West Brom in the cup and one at Tottenham. At Crystal Palace he added a fourth, a low cross from the overlap that Harvey Barnes finished, and by Thursday he led the club for assists with four in six starts.

    That is the strange part. The player who knows the system best made the two mistakes the system can least afford, and he made them in front of the whole squad.

    My gut tells me that Dedić will be the story of Monday night. Tino Livramento is out until after the international break and Lewis Miley, a midfielder who can cover at right-back in an emergency, is a doubt, so Dedić will probably start again. Everton will not need to be told where to look. A winger will run at him inside the first ten minutes, and I want to see a player with something to prove. The first month of his season says he has the tools to prove it.

    The rookie and the veteran

    Monday matters to both benches. Newcastle have lost three of their last four, and across the defeats at Leeds and Coventry and Thursday’s cup tie they have conceded eleven goals and scored three. Everton have scored eight league goals in eight games, lost 2-0 to both Chelsea and Arsenal before the cup win, and have yet to win away from home in the league. Moyes left out Jack Grealish, the Manchester City loanee, after he reportedly missed a training session, and still won comfortably without him. That says plenty about the grip he has on that dressing room.

    Moyes took charge of his first Premier League match in March 2002, when Jaissle was 13 years old. He is 63, reached 700 league matches in January 2025, and only Arsène Wenger and Sir Alex Ferguson have managed more. Jaissle, a young lad of just 38 years, will be managing his ninth Premier League match on Monday.

    He has won elsewhere, and it counts: the Austrian double in his first season at Salzburg, then back-to-back Asian Champions League titles at Al-Ahli. Nothing is like the Premier League, though, and Jaissle is learning that the hard way. He is a Premier League rookie facing a manager who has spent nearly a quarter of a century collecting every habit a rookie lacks.

    They have met twice since August, and Moyes has won both by the same score. The first, at Murrayfield in pre-season, was Jaissle’s second match in charge and came with ten changes at half-time, so I would not read much into it. The second, on Thursday, I would. Moyes has also won both of his league visits to St James’ Park since returning to Everton, 1-0 last May and 3-2 in February, and the side that scored first has won every meeting since last May, friendly included.

    Newcastle’s only win in that run, the 4-1 at Everton last November, began with Malick Thiaw heading in inside the opening minute. Afterwards Moyes said his team had been beaten by “a far more experienced looking team”. That line has aged oddly. Gordon went to Barcelona, Tonali to Tottenham and Guimarães to Arsenal this summer, and all eight of the new arrivals are 24 or younger.

    The cast list repeats itself. Barry has scored in each of his last three games against Newcastle, friendly included: the winner at St James’ Park in February, then Murrayfield, then Thursday. Garner supplied the corner for Jarrad Branthwaite’s header in February and scored on Thursday. Thiaw’s two headers in November remain the best afternoon any Newcastle player has had against a Moyes side.

    Two 3-1 scorelines look like a gulf, and I think they are the wrong evidence. On Thursday Newcastle had 28 shots, 57 per cent of the ball, 37 touches in the Everton box and ten corners, and Everton scored three times from five shots on target. The gulf is in the seconds after the ball turns over, where Moyes’s players know exactly what to do and Jaissle’s are still finding out.

    Lesson one: the Premier League is unforgiving

    Jaissle has two things to adapt, and the first is a habit of mind. In this league even a small mistake costs a goal, and it costs one quickly. Thursday’s three Everton goals began with a loose touch, a tackle Burn missed and a run nobody tracked. None of them needed a moment of quality from the opposition.

    Unai Emery’s Aston Villa won 1-0 at St James’ Park on 17 October, and the numbers from that night make uncomfortable reading. Newcastle had 16 shots worth 0.99 expected goals, a measure of chance quality, and Villa’s 15 were worth 1.57. In the second half Villa won 73 per cent of the ground duels, made 17 tackles to Newcastle’s seven and cleared the ball 24 times. Emery has said that clean sheets are what Villa have been working on. Moyes’s Everton did the same on Thursday: eight saves from Pickford, a last-ditch block from James Tarkowski on Will Osula, and three goals from five shots on target. Both men are happy to take risks, and both choose their moments.

    It is not as if Jaissle lacks the instinct. His own principles keep a spare player in or in front of the back line, and at Selhurst Park he squeezed the gap between his defenders and his forwards to 18.5 metres, down from 25.6 at Coventry. Newcastle won 2-0 and kept their first clean sheet since the end of August. Four days later, against Moyes, the old habit returned in the moments that matter, and Jaissle said as much himself when he called the first goal again a no-risk zone.

    This is the part only he can fix, and he has to fix it in the dressing room more than on the whiteboard. Safe is a decision, and a good one, in the right part of the pitch: clear it in your own half and take your gambles in the other. My view is that the Premier League has no room for courageous, gung-ho football all the time, and the managers who last in it are pragmatists as well as ideas men. “Being a young team is not an excuse any more,” Jaissle said on Thursday. He is right, and he has to be the one to teach it.

    Lesson two: believe the plan

    The second change is the happier one, because the team is already making it. Jaissle’s football is organised chaos: a high press, forwards leaping on the first pass after a turnover, the opposition’s defence broken before it has time to reset. Many of Newcastle’s goals this season began as turnovers high up the pitch. The players understand the plan now, and the numbers behind the results have started to show it.

    The results are a fair counter-argument, with two wins and three defeats in the last five games in all competitions. Look beneath them. At Villa the expected goals in the second half climbed from 0.21 to 0.78 after a half-time message about belief, and the team covered 118.4 kilometres, the most in any league game this season. At Palace the tighter shape produced a 2-0 win. On Thursday, even in defeat, Newcastle took 28 shots and had 37 touches in the Everton box, and in the second half they outshot Everton 17 to two.

    What they lack is the nerve to finish what the press creates. The stat sheet says 28 shots. The number I would give a lot to see is the one for the shots that were never taken: the moments when a player with space and a sight of goal looked up, saw a team-mate and passed the responsibility on. They are all over these games, and I think they come from fear. A forward who has just watched Dedić try to play out of trouble and pay for it will think twice before he tries something of his own, whether the shot, the run in behind or the killer pass that might be cut out. Every mistake in front of the dugout makes the next risk look more expensive.

    Jaissle said his half-time message at Villa was about belief, and the second half looked like a team that had heard it. After Thursday he said he probably needed to scream more. I would suggest the squad needs another voice, the one that says the next hesitation will cost more than the next miss. The club spent more than £265m on eight first-team arrivals this summer, and these are good players. They need to start believing it, and it is the manager’s job to make them.

    Put together, the two lessons are one instruction about geography: be careful in your own half and reckless in theirs.

    Monday night

    Kick-off at St James’ Park is 8pm, live on Sky. Newcastle are eighth on 11 points and Everton 11th on 10, and what follows is busy: Fulham away on Saturday, Livramento back after the international break, Arsenal at St James’ Park on 21 November. Everton host Coventry on Friday, with Fleetwood Town waiting in the cup quarter-finals in December.

    Somewhere early in the first half Pickford will hit a long kick forward, and a winger will close Dedić down near the touchline. The Gallowgate will see it before anyone else does. He can put the ball into the stand and take the grumbles, or he can try to play. Thursday should have taught him which to choose in his own half. The next test is whether the lesson holds the first time it matters.

  • Cup first: why Jaissle should send his best side to Everton on Thursday

    Everton v Newcastle Cup

    Newcastle meet Everton in the Carabao Cup on Thursday and in the Premier League on Monday, and Matthias Jaissle has the squad to spend his strongest players on the first.

    Malick Thiaw scored inside a minute on Newcastle’s last visit to the Hill Dickinson Stadium, and it was 3-0 by half-time.

    That was 29 November. Lewis Miley made it 2-0 on 25 minutes, Nick Woltemade made it 3-0 on 45, and Thiaw added a fourth after the break. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Everton’s attacking midfielder, found a consolation on 69. Eddie Howe picked that team and stepped down in July after nearly five years. Woltemade is on loan at Juventus. Miley sat out Sunday’s win at Crystal Palace with a glute injury. Thiaw is expected to start on Thursday.

    The ground sits on Bramley-Moore Dock, on the Mersey waterfront, with room for roughly 52,700. Newcastle have 7,732 of those seats, about one in seven, at £20 an adult and handed out in order of loyalty points. Kick-off is 7.45pm, under floodlights, on a late-October night beside the river.

    Two games, one opponent

    Four days after the Cup tie, Everton are at St James’ Park for the league. Jaissle has to pick two teams for the same opponent, and whatever he does on Thursday shapes Monday.

    He is three months into the job and the first eight league games have drawn criticism. Newcastle are eighth on 11 points from eight games, with a goal difference of minus two, a total that includes 4-1 defeats at Leeds United and Coventry City and a 1-0 home loss to Aston Villa. Jaissle spent last week defending his tactics in public. Then came Selhurst Park: Will Osula scored just after the break, Harvey Barnes on 58 minutes, and Newcastle had a first win there in six years and a first clean sheet since August.

    David Moyes, 63, has a week of his own to repair. Everton went unbeaten through their first six league games, then lost 2-0 at home to Chelsea and 2-0 at Arsenal without scoring in either. They are 11th on ten points, with two wins from four league games at home and goals hard to find. Three of the eighteen outfield players on their senior list are doubtful: Jarrad Branthwaite, the centre-back, with concussion, left-back Vitaliy Mykolenko with a knock, and winger Jack Grealish with an illness. Thierno Barry, a 24-year-old French centre-forward, is the only out-and-out striker on that list.

    The history is thin on comfort for Newcastle. Howe went four league games without a win against Everton from December 2023, starting with a 3-0 defeat at Goodison Park, and the 4-1 last November was the first victory of the run. Moyes, back at Everton since January 2025, has beaten Newcastle twice in three meetings.

    A first test against the old hand

    Jaissle was born in April 1988, when Moyes was a 24-year-old centre-back at Shrewsbury Town. Moyes took his first job in management, at Preston North End, in January 1998, when Jaissle was nine. He was appointed at Everton in March 2002, at 38, which is Jaissle’s age now, and his first Premier League match as a manager came against Fulham on 16 March that year. In January 2025 he became only the third man to manage 700 Premier League matches, after Arsène Wenger and Sir Alex Ferguson.

    Newcastle is Jaissle’s first job in English football. He was an assistant at Brøndby in Denmark, then a head coach at Salzburg in Austria and Al-Ahli in Saudi Arabia, and Thursday is his 11th competitive match with Newcastle. Moyes managed Everton alone for 518 games in his first spell.

    The gulf in experience is huge. The next two games will show whether it matters.

    The case for Thursday

    My view is that Jaissle should put his best eleven on the pitch at Everton and deal with Monday afterwards. On Tuesday he said he would go “all in” for the Cup and that supporters should expect “not too many changes”.

    The Cup is the one competition where Newcastle have a recent record to protect. A final in 2023, a quarter-final in 2024, the 2025 trophy that ended 70 years without a major domestic honour, a semi-final against Manchester City last winter. A last-eight place this season would be the fifth in a row. Howe won it. Jaissle arrives with two AFC Champions League titles from Al-Ahli, and a first trophy on Tyneside would settle a good many of the questions asked in October. Newcastle reached this round by beating West Bromwich Albion 3-2 and Millwall 1-0, and Everton by beating Preston North End 4-0 and Wolverhampton Wanderers 1-0.

    The squad numbers favour him. Newcastle spent about £265m on eight senior signings this summer, before add-ons, and a squad that size is there to be used. Moyes cannot do the same. With as few as fifteen fit outfield players he will pick largely the same group on Monday as on Thursday, whatever he does with the Cup side. If Moyes goes strong on Thursday, those players get four days before the trip north, and if he rotates, Newcastle’s best eleven meets an Everton side below full strength.

    Four days is ordinary recovery in the Premier League, so no one should promise tired legs on Monday. What Newcastle hold is a choice that Moyes mostly lacks.

    Extra time is the risk. Cup ties go to 120 minutes and then penalties, and a starting eleven that plays them all will feel it against Everton at the weekend. The bench decides those nights. Anthony Elanga and Jacob Ramsey are back from injury on managed minutes, and Bazoumana Touré and Aladji Bamba, the summer signings from Hoffenheim and Monaco, are waiting for minutes of their own.

    The price on Monday is real. Everton have won their last two visits to St James’ Park, 1-0 on the final day of 2024-25 through Charly Alcaraz, an attacking midfielder who is still on their books, and 3-2 last February, when Barry struck on 83 minutes, seconds after Jacob Murphy had levelled. Jordan Pickford, England’s goalkeeper, kept it that way with a late save. Newcastle have won one of their last six league meetings with Everton.

    Thursday’s eleven

    In a 4-2-3-1: Horníček; Dedić, Botman, Thiaw, Hall; González, Joelinton; Murphy, Willock, Barnes; Osula.

    Lukáš Horníček, the Czech goalkeeper signed from Braga for £25.7m, is expected to start both games, with Ewen Jaouen out until December. Amar Dedić, the Bosnian right-back from Benfica, has no natural cover while Tino Livramento is out, and Miley, the midfielder who steps in at right-back when needed, missed Sunday with a glute injury and is still a doubt. The centre-backs are the clearest call. Sven Botman and Thiaw are the first-choice pairing, started the Villa defeat and were rested at Selhurst Park, which leaves them fresh for a Cup night.

    Osula leads the line on form. He scored on Sunday, and Yoane Wissa, who wore the armband at Millwall, was dropped for Palace after the Villa defeat. Joe Willock plays behind Osula. He turned in Lewis Hall’s cutback for the 81st-minute winner at The Den in the last round, moments after Millwall’s Taïryk Arconte had hit the post. Murphy keeps his wing, and Barnes, who scored on Sunday, takes the other. Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the £51m forward signed from Lille on deadline day, missed Sunday through illness and is still a doubt, which leaves out the extra pace Jaissle might want against full-backs Moyes may have to improvise.

    Everton are likely to line up Pickford; Maitland-Niles, O’Brien, Tarkowski, Garner; Armstrong, Hackney; Dibling, Dewsbury-Hall, George; Barry. Ainsley Maitland-Niles, 29, would play at right-back and the veteran James Tarkowski, 33, would pair with Jake O’Brien, 25, in central defence. James Garner, a midfielder by trade, would play at left-back with Mykolenko doubtful. Hayden Hackney, a 24-year-old midfielder who breaks lines with the ball, and Harrison Armstrong, a 19-year-old, caught the eye at Murrayfield in pre-season, the only time Moyes and Jaissle have faced each other. Tyler Dibling and Tyrique George, both 20, would supply the width. Christian Nørgaard, the 32-year-old Danish midfielder, is still being eased back after a groin injury and is the player Moyes can bring on late to slow the game down.

    Monday

    In a 4-2-3-1: Horníček; Dedić, Schär, Burn, Hall; González, Joelinton; Touré, Ramsey, Elanga; Wissa.

    This is the back four that kept the clean sheet at Palace. Fabian Schär and Dan Burn, both 34, played that game, with Burn captaining, and a Cup-first week gives them one start and eight days between games. Botman and Thiaw sit down. They will meet Dibling and George, both 20, at a pace the older pair would not choose, which is the cost of the plan. Hall on the left and the González and Joelinton pairing in front of them will have to cover the gap.

    The front four come from Sunday’s bench. Touré, Ramsey, Elanga and Wissa have fresh legs and something to prove, and two of them are on managed minutes. If Ramsey or Elanga cannot start, Willock or Murphy stays in. Dedić plays again unless Livramento, listed as a knock with a return in early November, is back in time.

    St James’ Park has produced two draws, a win and a defeat in the league this season, in front of an average crowd of about 52,600. Monday night, 2 November, is the fifth home league game, under the lights, against a side that has won there twice running.

    Jaissle will have had Thursday’s result in hand for four days by then. A win in Liverpool would put Newcastle into the last eight for the fifth year running, where an away match against giant-killers, Fleetwood Town awaits.