Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Everton 3-1 Newcastle: the tie Newcastle gave away

by


Everton v Newcastle Match Report

Everton scored three goals at Hill Dickinson Stadium from just five shots on target. Newcastle took 28 shots, scored once and went out of the EFL Cup.

Jordan Pickford hits a long kick forward. Tyrique George, an Everton attacker, presses Amar Dedić, and the right-back tries to play his way out of trouble instead of putting the ball into the stands. Hayden Hackney, a holding midfielder, collects the loose ball and slides it to his midfield partner James Garner, who drives into the box and bends a shot into the far corner.

It is a low quality chance, the kind that rarely goes in. It is 1-0 after 34 minutes, and Newcastle have had the better of the early chances.

I keep coming back to how little it took. Nothing about the build-up was elaborate. A goalkeeper kicked it long, one forward ran at one defender, and a defender who could have ended the move by hitting the ball into the stands tried to play out of trouble instead.

Dedić has to shoulder some of the responsibility, because poor decision making led to the first goal.

The break that nobody stopped

The second goal comes as the first half runs out. Newcastle are pushing for an equaliser. Harvey Barnes drags a half-volley wide, then goes down in the box under Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s challenge and gets nothing from the referee. Then, with the half almost gone, Everton break.

Dewsbury-Hall, their attacking midfielder, takes the ball forward as the move gathers pace. Dan Burn is drawn too far up the pitch trying to make a tackle, misses it, and cannot stop him. Farai Hallam plays the advantage after a foul on Dewsbury-Hall, so the break runs on. The ball goes to Thierno Barry, Everton’s striker, whose cross finds Hackney, a holding midfielder who has made a late run into the box. Jacob Ramsey is slow to track him, and Hackney volleys into the bottom corner. It was a good chance, and he took it well.

Two errors, by two senior players. Burn committed himself to a tackle he did not win, and Ramsey did not follow a run he should have seen. Get either one right and the move is not a goal.

Newcastle finished the night with 57 per cent of the ball, 37 touches in the Everton box and ten corners. A side that spends a night in the opposition half still has to defend the moment the ball turns over. Both the second and third goals came from exactly that, and the third was the cleaner of the two.

It arrives 24 minutes into the second half, with Newcastle 2-0 down and chasing, and the ball goes loose in their own possession. Garner leads the break and feeds Dewsbury-Hall, who gets in behind Dedić. Dedić cannot catch him or stay close to him, so Dewsbury-Hall has time to play a simple cross for Barry. Nico González is in the path of the ball but out of position, and he cannot stop it. Barry comes into the night with an unwelcome statistic attached, because nobody in the Premier League has missed more big chances this season and his tally is already in double figures. But this time he takes one touch and sweeps it into the top corner without a hint of nerves.

Two more mistakes, and this time they belong to the new boys. Dedić joined from Benfica in August and González from Manchester City, and between them they did not deal with a simple ball across the area.

Chasing a game means taking some risk, and Matthias Jaissle’s side had to take plenty. Being loose with the ball while doing it is a different matter.

What was there to be won

The tie was available to Newcastle, and the first quarter of an hour showed it. Between the 12th and 14th minutes Barnes, Fabian Schär and Jacob Murphy each had an effort from inside the box, three decent chances in three minutes at 0-0. Any one of them going in changes what Everton can do. All three of their goals came from transitions, and transitions need space to run into.

The second half gave more. Newcastle took 17 shots to Everton’s two. Three times a Newcastle player struck the ball and could not keep it down: Lewis Hall’s volley in the fourth minute, Dan Burn’s header in the 55th and Anthony Elanga’s volley in the 63rd. Yoane Wissa had a header that went straight at Pickford. In the 72nd minute Joe Willock and Joelinton both had efforts inside the area, and both were kept out, the second by Jake O’Brien, Everton’s centre-back.

Pickford, England’s goalkeeper, made eight saves. Of Newcastle’s 28 shots, nine were blocked and ten missed the target, which leaves nine that he had to deal with, and he saved eight of them. Credit him for that. There is a caveat too. Nine of the 28 shots came from outside the box, and plenty of the rest were difficult chances. That is a lot of decent opportunities and very few clear cut ones, and decent opportunities need clean finishing to turn into goals.

Burn finally gets one at 88 minutes, heading in Willock’s cross at the far post. Some Newcastle supporters had started for the exits four minutes earlier. By then Everton led 3-0, and Pickford was in no hurry to hand the ball back for the restart.

The pattern

Leeds and Coventry went the same way. Across those two 4-1 defeats and Thursday, Newcastle have conceded eleven goals and scored three. In the league they have faced more shots than any other side, 138, after eight games under Jaissle. Those figures deserve honest attention.

They also describe a team in open, busy games under a new manager, with eight first-team arrivals this summer and Sandro Tonali and Bruno Guimarães among the departures. My view is that Newcastle deserved more than a consolation goal on Thursday, and that most of what went wrong was within their control. Mistakes of concentration and decision are the quickest kind to coach out of a group that is still learning to play together.

After Leeds and Coventry I felt disappointed. After Everton I felt frustrated, because I could point to the moments that changed it.

What comes next

Newcastle’s run of four successive EFL Cup quarter-finals is over. The rematch comes four days later, at St James’ Park on Monday at 8pm, in the league, with Newcastle eighth on 11 points and Everton eleventh on 10. Fulham away follows on Saturday.

Everton have a quarter-final against Fleetwood Town, their first in three years. They travel to Tyneside on Monday and host Coventry on Friday.

Response

  1. […] one right-back, and no brilliance required from the opposition. Dedić was not alone on the night. As I wrote on Friday, Dan Burn and Jacob Ramsey share the blame for Hackney’s goal just before half-time. But […]

You may also enjoy:

Club Davies Finance Jaissle Match Report Premier League Preview Rumours SCR Squad Strategy Tactics Transfers

Newcastle News