
Jacob Murphy scored with a shot that had a two per cent chance of going in. Rodrigo Muniz equalised three minutes later. Between the two goals sat a Newcastle side that had settled, at last, on a way of defending in this league.
Eighty minutes into a 9°C Saturday afternoon at Craven Cottage, César Palacios, a Fulham substitute from Spain, plays a pass across his own half that nobody is waiting for. Jacob Murphy is. He runs at the defence, cuts inside Calvin Bassey and hits a left-footed shot from 25 yards into the top corner.
It had a two per cent chance of going in.
Three minutes later Palacios crosses from the left. The ball strikes Malick Thiaw and runs loose, and Rodrigo Muniz, a Brazilian striker on as a substitute, gets a boot to it. It finishes 1-1.
Newcastle should have won, and the goalkeeper is the best evidence. Lukáš Horníček, the Czech who joined from Braga in August, pushed away Oscar Bobb’s shot early in the first half. He got down to a first-time strike from Josh King, Fulham’s 19-year-old playmaker, who had just been given his first England call-up. He palmed away a near-post header from Timothy Castagne, the Fulham right-back. Three minutes into added time Lewis Miley headed away a free-kick and the ball dropped to Ryan Sessegnon, who hit it first time for the top corner. Horníček got a hand to it and pushed it past the post.
Murphy was named player of the match. My vote goes to the goalkeeper.

In front of him, Thiaw and the captain Dan Burn gave Fulham’s striker Gonzalo García one clear chance all afternoon, a header from a corner that went over the bar. Burn came close to giving Newcastle the lead before half-time. Lewis Hall played a short corner to Murphy, Murphy crossed, and Burn poked the ball in at the near post. The goal was ruled out because Yoane Wissa had pulled Castagne’s shirt. Jaissle called it soft.
Nico González and Sean Steur, who is 18, sat in front of the back four and kept it shut. Their main job was Josh King, and he managed two shots and no chance for anyone else before Fulham took him off. Steur was the busier of the two. He made nine defensive contributions, more than any other Newcastle midfielder.
The slot in front of them is a different matter. Wissa came off after an hour having made little of it. Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the 21-year-old Belgian who cost £51m from Lille on deadline day, arrived in the 74th minute and was pushed off the ball too easily. I would put a No 10 at the top of the January list.

Ten games
On 2 November, after Everton won 1-0 at St James’ Park, the home supporters booed Jaissle off. Five days later, at Craven Cottage, his team looked like something he could build on. I wanted to see whether the numbers said the same.
August
The first three league games brought five points. No Newcastle manager had taken four from his first two since Sam Allardyce in 2007-08.
Against Liverpool on the opening day Newcastle led 2-1 until Dominik Szoboszlai scored a penalty deep into stoppage time. Liverpool had shot more than twice as often. Tottenham and Bournemouth each had 17 shots, and by the third game no side in the division had faced more. Sven Botman, who started the first seven league games, kept making mistakes that led to shots. He had five by early November, the most in the league.
Newcastle in August went forward quickly and were exposed whenever the ball was lost.
September and October
The next experiment ran the other way. Newcastle kept the ball: more than half of it on average, and two-thirds at Coventry, where they had more than twice as many shots as the home side and lost 4-1. They had lost 4-1 at Leeds a month earlier. A team that gives the ball away high up the pitch is open when it does, and Leeds and Coventry punished it.
Selhurst Park to Craven Cottage
Then came Selhurst Park. Jaissle brought back Burn and Fabian Schär in central defence, put William Osula up front and let Palace have the ball. Newcastle won 2-0.

Opponents now get about half the open-play chances against Newcastle that they got in August. Possession is back where it started, so the ball is not what changed. At Craven Cottage Newcastle gave up fewer chances than in any of the ten games and made more interceptions than in any other. By my count they defended in a 5-4-1, which I had not seen from Jaissle before.

Averaging where each player touched the ball shows the team being squeezed together. In August the midfield sat close to the defence and a long way from the forwards, which is how a team that goes long looks on the map. In the middle weeks the midfield moved up to join the forwards and left the defence behind, and the widest gap of all opened at Coventry. Over the last three games the whole team has been about a third tighter than in August. The defenders play higher, the forwards a little deeper, and the midfield sits between them. Everton, a game Newcastle lost, was the tightest of the ten. Hull in September came close, but it did not last.
These are touch locations and not tracking, and they cover the whole match, so a side chasing a game sits differently from one that is leading it.
The attack changed shape too. At Everton, Newcastle shot from distance and seldom troubled the goalkeeper. Five days later at Fulham they had fewer shots, taken from closer in, and made three big chances. Barnes’s shots alone were worth 0.66 expected goals, and none went in.
The cost is at set pieces. Palace and Everton got most of their chances from corners and free kicks, and Thierno Barry’s goal at St James’ Park came from one.
The minutes
The players who have played most tell the same story.

Horníček has played every minute of the ten games, and his rating follows how much work he is given: high in August, low in the Leeds and Coventry weeks, high again lately. Hall has played nearly every minute and has hardly dropped below good.
The centre of defence changed. Botman improved through the middle weeks and lost his place after the Villa defeat. Thiaw had a modest spell, sat out at Palace and Everton and was among the better players at Fulham beside Burn.
González started slowly. By Coventry he was Newcastle’s best player, and again at Palace. He and Miley both improved sharply between the first four weeks and the next four. Steur has played less, but against Hull he was one of the best on the pitch.
The front line has less to show. Barnes has played almost every minute and did his best work before Everton. Wissa scored at Tottenham in the second game, and his ratings since have stayed in the sixes. So have Pardo’s, in six appearances.
The last graphic ranks everyone with 250 minutes or more. Murphy, Hall and Elanga head the table, although Murphy and Elanga have played less than half of Hall’s minutes. Hornícek and Barnes, who have played nearly every minute, sit fourth and fifth. Pardo is last.

Arsenal
Newcastle have taken four points from their last nine, and the balance of chances over the last three games is no better than over the four before. The set pieces leak. The attack has not arrived. Three games is a small sample.
The international break comes first. Then Arsenal arrive at St James’ Park on Saturday 21 November for a 5.30pm Sky kick-off, as league leaders on 27 points after Martin Ødegaard’s winner against Hull. Fulham go to Manchester City the same day. Newcastle are 11th on 12 points, and the Tyne-Wear derby follows on 6 December.
Arsenal will tell me more than Fulham did.
Match statistics, ratings and touch locations are from FotMob, using Opta data. Performance grades are from Gradient Sports.














