Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Match Report

  • Ten games to find a shape

    Fulham v Newcastle Match Report

    Jacob Murphy scored with a shot that had a two per cent chance of going in. Rodrigo Muniz equalised three minutes later. Between the two goals sat a Newcastle side that had settled, at last, on a way of defending in this league.

    Eighty minutes into a 9°C Saturday afternoon at Craven Cottage, César Palacios, a Fulham substitute from Spain, plays a pass across his own half that nobody is waiting for. Jacob Murphy is. He runs at the defence, cuts inside Calvin Bassey and hits a left-footed shot from 25 yards into the top corner.

    It had a two per cent chance of going in.

    Three minutes later Palacios crosses from the left. The ball strikes Malick Thiaw and runs loose, and Rodrigo Muniz, a Brazilian striker on as a substitute, gets a boot to it. It finishes 1-1.

    Newcastle should have won, and the goalkeeper is the best evidence. Lukáš Horníček, the Czech who joined from Braga in August, pushed away Oscar Bobb’s shot early in the first half. He got down to a first-time strike from Josh King, Fulham’s 19-year-old playmaker, who had just been given his first England call-up. He palmed away a near-post header from Timothy Castagne, the Fulham right-back. Three minutes into added time Lewis Miley headed away a free-kick and the ball dropped to Ryan Sessegnon, who hit it first time for the top corner. Horníček got a hand to it and pushed it past the post.

    Murphy was named player of the match. My vote goes to the goalkeeper.

    In front of him, Thiaw and the captain Dan Burn gave Fulham’s striker Gonzalo García one clear chance all afternoon, a header from a corner that went over the bar. Burn came close to giving Newcastle the lead before half-time. Lewis Hall played a short corner to Murphy, Murphy crossed, and Burn poked the ball in at the near post. The goal was ruled out because Yoane Wissa had pulled Castagne’s shirt. Jaissle called it soft.

    Nico González and Sean Steur, who is 18, sat in front of the back four and kept it shut. Their main job was Josh King, and he managed two shots and no chance for anyone else before Fulham took him off. Steur was the busier of the two. He made nine defensive contributions, more than any other Newcastle midfielder.

    The slot in front of them is a different matter. Wissa came off after an hour having made little of it. Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the 21-year-old Belgian who cost £51m from Lille on deadline day, arrived in the 74th minute and was pushed off the ball too easily. I would put a No 10 at the top of the January list.

    Ten games

    On 2 November, after Everton won 1-0 at St James’ Park, the home supporters booed Jaissle off. Five days later, at Craven Cottage, his team looked like something he could build on. I wanted to see whether the numbers said the same.

    August

    The first three league games brought five points. No Newcastle manager had taken four from his first two since Sam Allardyce in 2007-08.

    Against Liverpool on the opening day Newcastle led 2-1 until Dominik Szoboszlai scored a penalty deep into stoppage time. Liverpool had shot more than twice as often. Tottenham and Bournemouth each had 17 shots, and by the third game no side in the division had faced more. Sven Botman, who started the first seven league games, kept making mistakes that led to shots. He had five by early November, the most in the league.

    Newcastle in August went forward quickly and were exposed whenever the ball was lost.

    September and October

    The next experiment ran the other way. Newcastle kept the ball: more than half of it on average, and two-thirds at Coventry, where they had more than twice as many shots as the home side and lost 4-1. They had lost 4-1 at Leeds a month earlier. A team that gives the ball away high up the pitch is open when it does, and Leeds and Coventry punished it.

    Selhurst Park to Craven Cottage

    Then came Selhurst Park. Jaissle brought back Burn and Fabian Schär in central defence, put William Osula up front and let Palace have the ball. Newcastle won 2-0.

    Opponents now get about half the open-play chances against Newcastle that they got in August. Possession is back where it started, so the ball is not what changed. At Craven Cottage Newcastle gave up fewer chances than in any of the ten games and made more interceptions than in any other. By my count they defended in a 5-4-1, which I had not seen from Jaissle before.

    Averaging where each player touched the ball shows the team being squeezed together. In August the midfield sat close to the defence and a long way from the forwards, which is how a team that goes long looks on the map. In the middle weeks the midfield moved up to join the forwards and left the defence behind, and the widest gap of all opened at Coventry. Over the last three games the whole team has been about a third tighter than in August. The defenders play higher, the forwards a little deeper, and the midfield sits between them. Everton, a game Newcastle lost, was the tightest of the ten. Hull in September came close, but it did not last.

    These are touch locations and not tracking, and they cover the whole match, so a side chasing a game sits differently from one that is leading it.

    The attack changed shape too. At Everton, Newcastle shot from distance and seldom troubled the goalkeeper. Five days later at Fulham they had fewer shots, taken from closer in, and made three big chances. Barnes’s shots alone were worth 0.66 expected goals, and none went in.

    The cost is at set pieces. Palace and Everton got most of their chances from corners and free kicks, and Thierno Barry’s goal at St James’ Park came from one.

    The minutes

    The players who have played most tell the same story.

    Horníček has played every minute of the ten games, and his rating follows how much work he is given: high in August, low in the Leeds and Coventry weeks, high again lately. Hall has played nearly every minute and has hardly dropped below good.

    The centre of defence changed. Botman improved through the middle weeks and lost his place after the Villa defeat. Thiaw had a modest spell, sat out at Palace and Everton and was among the better players at Fulham beside Burn.

    González started slowly. By Coventry he was Newcastle’s best player, and again at Palace. He and Miley both improved sharply between the first four weeks and the next four. Steur has played less, but against Hull he was one of the best on the pitch.

    The front line has less to show. Barnes has played almost every minute and did his best work before Everton. Wissa scored at Tottenham in the second game, and his ratings since have stayed in the sixes. So have Pardo’s, in six appearances.

    The last graphic ranks everyone with 250 minutes or more. Murphy, Hall and Elanga head the table, although Murphy and Elanga have played less than half of Hall’s minutes. Hornícek and Barnes, who have played nearly every minute, sit fourth and fifth. Pardo is last.

    Arsenal

    Newcastle have taken four points from their last nine, and the balance of chances over the last three games is no better than over the four before. The set pieces leak. The attack has not arrived. Three games is a small sample.

    The international break comes first. Then Arsenal arrive at St James’ Park on Saturday 21 November for a 5.30pm Sky kick-off, as league leaders on 27 points after Martin Ødegaard’s winner against Hull. Fulham go to Manchester City the same day. Newcastle are 11th on 12 points, and the Tyne-Wear derby follows on 6 December.

    Arsenal will tell me more than Fulham did.

    Match statistics, ratings and touch locations are from FotMob, using Opta data. Performance grades are from Gradient Sports.

  • The Note on the Grass

    Newcastle vs Everton Match Report

    A 1–0 home defeat to Everton left Newcastle 13th, Matthias Jaissle jeered on the lap of appreciation and a dropped sheet of paper carrying the argument. It also left a question that the manager’s own answers did not settle.

    Eighty-seven minutes in, with rain slanting through the St James’ Park floodlights, Bazoumana Touré jogs onto the pitch holding a sheet of paper. Fabian Schär takes a quick look. Then he lets it drop.

    The broadcast cameras find it on the wet turf: names in blue ink, Osula and Wissa across the top, Murphy and Steur lower down. Before the night is out, social media has spoken: the players, have stopped listening to Matthias Jaissle.

    It is a neat story, maybe it’s true. The note was dumped on the pitch because the players don’t care anymore.

    What the eye saw

    Monday nights have been unkind to Newcastle for some time. They have lost 21 of their last 32 league games on the day, including both this season, 4–1 to Leeds and 4–1 to Coventry. This one starts promisingly enough, then drifts into the worst first half they have produced all season. The ball goes long, again and again, towards William Osula, who has touched it five times by the half-hour. Barely a quarter of those long balls find a team-mate. There is no pattern to the play, no obvious idea about who should be where, and no tempo until Everton choose to supply it. Thierno Barry, Everton’s French striker, spurns one clear chance and Harrison Armstrong, a young Everton midfielder, shoots wide with the goal at his mercy. The score at the break is 0–0 only because Everton are generous. The boos at the whistle come from a minority. They will not stay a minority for long.

    The second half is better, though not by much. Elanga’s touch at the back post spins off Jordan Pickford and the upright and along the goal line. Jacob Ramsey drives a clean strike inches past the post. But Newcastle’s first shot on target, a tame 25-yarder from Yoane Wissa, does not arrive until the 85th minute.

    By then they are behind, and the goal is the sort that hurts. Everton take a quick free kick after Joelinton and Barry tangle in Newcastle’s half. James Garner plays it short, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall feeds Tyrique George, and George’s shot goes straight at Lukas Hornicek. It squirms beneath the goalkeeper, and Barry taps into an empty net. Newcastle appeal for a foul on Schär in the build-up and for offside. VAR takes its time and gives neither.

    It is another error leading to a goal. Newcastle’s count of those had reached four by the hour on Opta’s numbers, bettered only by Sunderland and Hull, and this one belonged to the goalkeeper. Hornicek makes several good saves afterwards, but the damage is done and the home crowd knows it.

    The Note

    Touré replaces Amar Dedić at 87 minutes and carries the sheet on. Players arriving with a note from the bench is a familiar sight, a way of passing a change of shape through the noise without shouting. What Schär did with this one has been read as contempt. I cannot see inside his head, no one can. Dropping a note after reading it is as consistent with a player who has absorbed it as with one who has ignored it.

    It could be a symptom or it could be nothing, and the truth is that nobody outside the dressing room knows which. The evidence on Schär is mixed. FotMob rates him Newcastle’s best outfield player on the night, and he is booked in the scuffle at the end. But on a night when the manager himself says the plan was not followed, a centre-half dropping a team sheet on the turf is not a picture anyone at the club will have wanted.

    Touré’s three minutes on the pitch do produce the best move of the night. Barnes finds him down the left, he reaches the byline and pulls it back, and Pickford saves Wissa’s shot with his right boot. Moments later Ramsey is sent off for two yellow cards in the space of two minutes, the second for catching Armstrong’s ankle. The final whistle brings the loudest booing of the evening.

    A manager on the defensive

    In the press room, Jaissle sounds defensive. He knew the questions would be hard, and he answers them by spreading the weight around.

    He talks about a week of good training that did not make it onto the pitch. He says the plan was to press high at home and to build through patterns, and that his side were “not brave enough in possession”. He is blunt about the long balls: “Long balls was not the plan.” He says the goal should have been disallowed for a foul on Schär. He accepts the unforced error that led to the free kick, says the team was “just sleeping”, and allows that on a better day the goalkeeper saves George’s shot. And in among it all he says: “I am responsible for that.”

    The ownership is there, but it arrives in general terms, while the specifics he offers point at the pitch and the officials. That produces the conflict in the coverage. Some of the next-morning headlines have him blaming the players for ignoring his instructions. Others stress that he took responsibility, and the recording supports both readings. If the long balls were not the plan, then either the players did not carry out the plan or the plan was not clear enough to survive the first bad ten minutes. The note may be a symptom of that disagreement, and it may just be a piece of paper.

    What it means

    The lack of confidence is the issue here, and the pattern behind it is easy to see. Newcastle have conceded in all five home league games this season and have gone 14 straight home league games without a clean sheet, the longest run in the club’s league history. A side braced for the next mistake will often play it long to avoid its own half. That is a fixable habit, and Jaissle is nine league games into a new job with a squad that has changed a great deal since the summer.

    He indicated he will not tear up the team after one bad night, because players need to feel one poor performance will not cost them their place. He also left a door open: anyone pushing hard in training makes the choice easier, and Sean Steur, who made an encouraging cameo, is clearly in his thinking.

    The next test is Fulham away on Saturday at 3pm, the last match before the international break. Ramsey’s red brings an automatic one-match suspension. After the break comes Arsenal at St James’ Park on 21 November, the league leaders fresh from a 1–0 win at Anfield, and then Brighton away on 29 November, a side sitting third on 19 points. The table still gives Newcastle some room: they are on 11 points, four clear of 18th. The fixtures give them very little.

    Everton, up to seventh on 13 points, have their first away league win of the season, and David Moyes’s side now turn to Coventry.

    On Saturday at Craven Cottage, a new sheet will be written, handed across and read. Plenty of people will be watching to see what Schär does with it.

  • Everton 3-1 Newcastle: the tie Newcastle gave away

    Everton v Newcastle Match Report

    Everton scored three goals at Hill Dickinson Stadium from just five shots on target. Newcastle took 28 shots, scored once and went out of the EFL Cup.

    Jordan Pickford hits a long kick forward. Tyrique George, an Everton attacker, presses Amar Dedić, and the right-back tries to play his way out of trouble instead of putting the ball into the stands. Hayden Hackney, a holding midfielder, collects the loose ball and slides it to his midfield partner James Garner, who drives into the box and bends a shot into the far corner.

    It is a low quality chance, the kind that rarely goes in. It is 1-0 after 34 minutes, and Newcastle have had the better of the early chances.

    I keep coming back to how little it took. Nothing about the build-up was elaborate. A goalkeeper kicked it long, one forward ran at one defender, and a defender who could have ended the move by hitting the ball into the stands tried to play out of trouble instead.

    Dedić has to shoulder some of the responsibility, because poor decision making led to the first goal.

    The break that nobody stopped

    The second goal comes as the first half runs out. Newcastle are pushing for an equaliser. Harvey Barnes drags a half-volley wide, then goes down in the box under Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s challenge and gets nothing from the referee. Then, with the half almost gone, Everton break.

    Dewsbury-Hall, their attacking midfielder, takes the ball forward as the move gathers pace. Dan Burn is drawn too far up the pitch trying to make a tackle, misses it, and cannot stop him. Farai Hallam plays the advantage after a foul on Dewsbury-Hall, so the break runs on. The ball goes to Thierno Barry, Everton’s striker, whose cross finds Hackney, a holding midfielder who has made a late run into the box. Jacob Ramsey is slow to track him, and Hackney volleys into the bottom corner. It was a good chance, and he took it well.

    Two errors, by two senior players. Burn committed himself to a tackle he did not win, and Ramsey did not follow a run he should have seen. Get either one right and the move is not a goal.

    Newcastle finished the night with 57 per cent of the ball, 37 touches in the Everton box and ten corners. A side that spends a night in the opposition half still has to defend the moment the ball turns over. Both the second and third goals came from exactly that, and the third was the cleaner of the two.

    It arrives 24 minutes into the second half, with Newcastle 2-0 down and chasing, and the ball goes loose in their own possession. Garner leads the break and feeds Dewsbury-Hall, who gets in behind Dedić. Dedić cannot catch him or stay close to him, so Dewsbury-Hall has time to play a simple cross for Barry. Nico González is in the path of the ball but out of position, and he cannot stop it. Barry comes into the night with an unwelcome statistic attached, because nobody in the Premier League has missed more big chances this season and his tally is already in double figures. But this time he takes one touch and sweeps it into the top corner without a hint of nerves.

    Two more mistakes, and this time they belong to the new boys. Dedić joined from Benfica in August and González from Manchester City, and between them they did not deal with a simple ball across the area.

    Chasing a game means taking some risk, and Matthias Jaissle’s side had to take plenty. Being loose with the ball while doing it is a different matter.

    What was there to be won

    The tie was available to Newcastle, and the first quarter of an hour showed it. Between the 12th and 14th minutes Barnes, Fabian Schär and Jacob Murphy each had an effort from inside the box, three decent chances in three minutes at 0-0. Any one of them going in changes what Everton can do. All three of their goals came from transitions, and transitions need space to run into.

    The second half gave more. Newcastle took 17 shots to Everton’s two. Three times a Newcastle player struck the ball and could not keep it down: Lewis Hall’s volley in the fourth minute, Dan Burn’s header in the 55th and Anthony Elanga’s volley in the 63rd. Yoane Wissa had a header that went straight at Pickford. In the 72nd minute Joe Willock and Joelinton both had efforts inside the area, and both were kept out, the second by Jake O’Brien, Everton’s centre-back.

    Pickford, England’s goalkeeper, made eight saves. Of Newcastle’s 28 shots, nine were blocked and ten missed the target, which leaves nine that he had to deal with, and he saved eight of them. Credit him for that. There is a caveat too. Nine of the 28 shots came from outside the box, and plenty of the rest were difficult chances. That is a lot of decent opportunities and very few clear cut ones, and decent opportunities need clean finishing to turn into goals.

    Burn finally gets one at 88 minutes, heading in Willock’s cross at the far post. Some Newcastle supporters had started for the exits four minutes earlier. By then Everton led 3-0, and Pickford was in no hurry to hand the ball back for the restart.

    The pattern

    Leeds and Coventry went the same way. Across those two 4-1 defeats and Thursday, Newcastle have conceded eleven goals and scored three. In the league they have faced more shots than any other side, 138, after eight games under Jaissle. Those figures deserve honest attention.

    They also describe a team in open, busy games under a new manager, with eight first-team arrivals this summer and Sandro Tonali and Bruno Guimarães among the departures. My view is that Newcastle deserved more than a consolation goal on Thursday, and that most of what went wrong was within their control. Mistakes of concentration and decision are the quickest kind to coach out of a group that is still learning to play together.

    After Leeds and Coventry I felt disappointed. After Everton I felt frustrated, because I could point to the moments that changed it.

    What comes next

    Newcastle’s run of four successive EFL Cup quarter-finals is over. The rematch comes four days later, at St James’ Park on Monday at 8pm, in the league, with Newcastle eighth on 11 points and Everton eleventh on 10. Fulham away follows on Saturday.

    Everton have a quarter-final against Fleetwood Town, their first in three years. They travel to Tyneside on Monday and host Coventry on Friday.

  • Newcastle 2, Crystal Palace 0: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

    Crystal Palace v Newcastle Match Review

    A first away league win since August, a first clean sheet since the same weekend, and a first half Matthias Jaissle’s side would rather forget.

    Three minutes in, Adam Wharton, Palace’s England midfielder, floated a free-kick into the Newcastle penalty area and the ball refused to leave. Axel Disasi, the French centre-half, swung at it twice and was blocked twice. Jean-Philippe Mateta, the French striker who scored twice against Newcastle on this ground in April, got two clean looks of his own. Lukáš Horníček, the 24-year-old Czech goalkeeper, kept out both.

    Four efforts inside a minute, worth a little over a goal by FotMob’s reckoning. Selhurst Park, 25,018 strong on a bright, mild Sunday, roared like a ground that believed its season was about to turn. Palace had lost 5-0 at Brighton a week earlier, and Pierre Sage, their head coach, needed something to hold. For twenty minutes he had it. By half-time his side had taken eight shots, and Newcastle four.

    Newcastle won 2-0 anyway. William Osula scored in the 47th minute and Harvey Barnes in the 58th, which gave Newcastle their first league win on the road since Tottenham on 29 August, and their first clean sheet since that same afternoon. Getting there needs sorting into the good, the bad and the ugly.

    THE GOOD

    Nico González finds his feet. For weeks he has looked like a player still arriving. On Sunday he arrived. The Spaniard held the middle of the pitch with a calm that spread outwards: unhurried on the ball, never still off it, and finished with eight recoveries and three dribbles attempted, all three completed. In the way he drifted into pockets and found the pass early, there were moments that recalled Bruno Guimarães.

    He is not quick. When a Palace attacker got past him in the first half, González grabbed what he could, took a yellow card on 36 minutes, and so collected his second booking in as many games after the one against Villa. That is the cost. The return is larger. Jaissle kept picking him through the Villa defeat and said on Friday that he was pleased with his progress, because a run of games was always the route to match fitness. This was the first proper payment on it, and he looks like a man with more to give.

    Burn’s return gives the back line a spine. Dan Burn came back as captain and the defence took his shape. Jaissle left out Sven Botman and Malick Thiaw for him and Fabian Schär, and Burn cleared seven times, five of them with his head. Palace put 17 shots towards the Newcastle goal. Four were on target, two of those in the third-minute scramble, and Horníček saved all four.

    Jaissle adjusts. He said he would change things after Villa and he did: five alterations, a 4-2-3-1 with González and Joelinton paired in front of the defence, and a game plan that dropped the approach behind the defeats at Coventry and against Villa. In both, the front line pushed up near the opposition box and the side stretched from back to front. At Selhurst Park Newcastle squeezed. FotMob’s touch locations put the gap between the defenders’ average position and the forwards’ at 18.5 metres, the tightest of Newcastle’s eight league games and well inside the 22 against Villa and 25.6 at Coventry. The attackers sat about seven metres deeper than in either of those matches, and the side was a little narrower than at any other point this season. Nearly half of Newcastle’s attacks, 49%, came down the left, the highest share of the eight games. Whether it is better football is another matter, but it is a response, and finding one after two defeats is the job.

    Newcastle’s touch maps for the win at Palace and the defeats at Villa, Coventry and Leeds. The bracket marks the distance between the average position of the defenders and the forwards. Source: FotMob touch locations.

    THE BAD

    The centre-halves. Schär and Burn are both 34. They organise well and win headers, and neither has been quick for years. Palace took three shots off the break, at 7, 12 and 85 minutes. None hurt Newcastle, and Palace were caught offside four times, which says the line stepped up and held. It is a gamble all the same, and Arsenal arrive at St James’ Park on 21 November level on points at the top with Manchester City, who follow on Boxing Day. A high line with those legs behind it will not get such an easy afternoon against either of them.

    Murphy and Willock were both poor. Each had one moment worth remembering and very little to put beside it.

    Jacob Murphy’s low, early cross put Newcastle ahead, and it was a lovely piece of work. For long stretches around it he was a spectator in the attack, touching the ball 32 times in 90 minutes, fewer than any other outfield starter bar Osula, and attempting only 14 passes all afternoon. He ran the right flank up and down and covered his full-back without complaint, and nobody doubts the engine. A winger on 14 passes is still not giving a team much.

    Joe Willock had his own moment: Joelinton’s through ball, a clean finish across Walter Benítez in the Palace goal, and a VAR flag for moving a fraction too early. Take that away and the afternoon was thin. He won four of 13 ground duels, completed one of five dribbles, made one tackle and one clearance, and finished with FotMob’s lowest rating of any Newcastle starter, 6.4. He gave little with the ball and little without it. Ramsey and Elanga, who replaced Willock and Barnes at 77, are only just back from injury. As the rest of the squad returns to fitness, the question is how Murphy and Willock fit in, and on this evidence their place may be the bench.

    THE UGLY

    The first half. It was grim. Newcastle managed four shots, every one blocked or off target. Palace, who had taken eight, were unlucky not to be ahead. The ball went sideways, then backwards, then nowhere. Had Mateta finished either of his early chances, Jaissle would have been standing at half-time with a plan in pieces.

    The second half. Something Jaissle said in the dressing room worked inside two minutes. Murphy crossed and Osula finished in the 47th. Willock’s goal went to VAR and came back offside in the 52nd. Barnes made it two in the 58th, finishing from Amar Dedić’s low cross from the overlap. Newcastle had two shots on target all afternoon and scored with both. It was the best half of away football they have played this season, and the competition is not stiff: Newcastle lost 4-1 at both Leeds and Coventry.

    Which raises an awkward question. Palace had played in Istanbul on Thursday night, a 2-2 draw with Beşiktaş in the Europa League, and kicked off roughly 64 hours after the final whistle there. Sage changed nobody. The eleven who started in Turkey were the eleven who started at Selhurst Park, and after the break they looked it. Did fatigue, physical and mental, work against them? Palace played Lyon, Brighton, Beşiktaş and Newcastle in 11 days and won none of the four. They know Thursday nights, having won the Conference League in May for the club’s first European trophy, but that run ended with Oliver Glasner leaving, and Sage may be inheriting a squad still carrying the load. Newcastle know the feeling. Their Champions League campaign last season ran alongside a league campaign that sat mid-table that autumn, and the league is usually where the cost of European football shows up. A 5-0 defeat at Brighton followed by a night in Istanbul is a lot to carry into Selhurst Park, and the second half looked as much like a mental collapse as a physical one.

    WHAT’S NEXT

    Newcastle’s next game is at Everton on Thursday (7.45pm) in the fourth round of the EFL Cup, with the same opponents due at St James’ Park for the league on Monday night. Expect David Moyes to set Everton up in a compact block, as they did in Saturday’s 2-0 defeat at Arsenal, where they defended well for long spells and were undone by a corner and a header. Thierno Barry, their centre-forward, won 11 duels in that game, so the centre-halves face an evening of physical work, and set pieces will matter, since that was where Palace hurt Newcastle in the opening minutes at Selhurst Park. On the line is a place in the last eight, and a first test of whether this tighter shape can create chances against a side that gives away little space.

    Palace are at Fulham in the same competition on Wednesday.

  • Give Jaissle Time

    Patience

    Newcastle have lost three of their first seven league games, and the boos have already started. Panic now would cost the club more than the defeats have.

    In the 36th minute against Aston Villa on 17 October, João Gomes, Villa’s Brazilian midfielder, finds space on the right and crosses. Johan Manzambi, the 20-year-old Swiss attacking midfielder Newcastle had agreed a £49m fee for in July before Villa went higher, heads it past Lukáš Horníček.

    Watch it back and every Newcastle player near the ball has a job. Harvey Barnes, on the left, keeps his eye on Matty Cash, Villa’s right-back, overlapping behind the play. Lewis Hall stays tight to a runner cutting inside. Closing down Gomes falls to the midfield, and Nico González gets there late. After 35 minutes of chasing the ball high up the pitch he looks like a man who has run out of air.

    It was not a one-off. In the third game of the season, Bournemouth had 13 first-half shots at St James’ Park and one match report spoke of a team running out of steam. Jaissle said much the same after beating Hull: the legs went late, with nine players missing. At Coventry, Newcastle had 67% of the ball and 19 shots to nine and conceded four. ‘We controlled many phases but it’s not enough,’ Jaissle told the BBC.

    The plan is clear. González, signed from Manchester City for a reported £50m, told NUFC TV that Jaissle ‘wants direct football, intense’, with the ball won back high the moment it is lost. The midfielders who could have run all day for that, Bruno Guimarães and Sandro Tonali, left in the summer. González is a passer, and a good one: on his debut at Tottenham he lifted a long ball inside the first minute that led to a clear chance. Analysts who charted the early games noted that he drops between his centre-backs in build-up, so he starts attacks from deep and is then expected to sprint out and shut down the winger when they break down. At Villa he was late doing the second job.


    That adds up to a job half done, and the people meant to finish it need the time to do it.

    I have watched this happen at work whenever a new boss arrives with a new strategy. The people were hired for the old plan, and the new plan doesn’t alter what they are good at. Nobody sensible expects them to change in a few weeks. González won’t become an elite presser in two months, and no amount of booing will speed it up. The sensible route is to build the game around what the squad does well today and plan the move towards Jaissle’s ideal over a longer period. Some players switch quickly. Joelinton arrived at Newcastle as a striker and became one of the best midfielders in the league. Most take far longer.

    Newcastle supporters need no lecture on this, because we lived it. Eddie Howe took over a club that was 19th in November 2021 and spent most of that season in the bottom three. We finished 11th, and the year after we were in the Champions League. The same story runs through the league. Pep Guardiola ended his first year at Manchester City third and without a trophy, then won the title with 100 points. Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool finished eighth in his first season and were champions four years later. Clubs that waited were rewarded for it.

    Why should Newcastle give him this time? Start with what he did at Al-Ahli. He took over a side that had only just been promoted and came close to being sacked early in the 2024-25 season. The club’s board resisted a knee-jerk reaction and backed him to turn it around, and Al-Ahli’s fans reportedly protested when the club weighed replacing him with Massimiliano Allegri that January. He survived, finished that campaign as champion of Asia, and won it again the year after. Along the way he rebuilt his own football. At Salzburg he ran a young, pressing-first side. At Al-Ahli he had to fit Riyad Mahrez, Roberto Firmino, Ivan Toney and Franck Kessié into a 4-2-3-1, with more weight on defensive organisation and quick counter-attacks down the flanks. A data review of his Saudi years found that Al-Ahli became less possession-heavy and less busy without the ball, and defended better anyway, because the press became more efficient. He kept his principles and changed the workload. That is the skill Newcastle need from him now, and he has already shown it under heavier pressure than a poor October. After Coventry he said the formation was not the issue. If he is right, the thing that has to flex is what he asks of the players inside it.

    The second reason is what the failures look like. Legs fading late, one midfielder carrying two jobs and nobody named to pick up the crosser are coaching problems, and coaching problems get fixed on a training ground. They don’t suggest a dressing room that has stopped listening. Five days after the 4-1 defeat at Leeds, Newcastle beat Hull 2-1 with goals in the third and seventh minutes, with nine players missing. At Coventry they had most of the ball and 19 shots. That is a squad that wants to do what it is told and is finding the limits of what it can do, which gives a good coach something to work with.

    I’d start with the press. A side that cannot sustain it for 90 minutes can still press well for 20, with spells in a mid-block when the legs go and the whole team resetting its shape together. It costs a little ambition and it protects the legs of a midfield that has not yet been built for the full 90.

    Then I’d give the wide channel an owner. When the full-backs push up in build-up, someone has to be named to pick up the crosser if the ball is lost, and the rule has to be drilled until nobody needs to think about it.

    González’s own job comes next. He does one of his two tasks far better than the other, and it is the one Jaissle bought him for. A midfield partner who covers ground would let him remain a passer.

    The last adjustment is about listening. Ted Lasso is a fictional American football coach who is suddenly hired, in the television series of the same name, to manage a Premier League club. He was an outsider learning an unfamiliar league in a hurry, and the useful part of that story was how he asked the people who already knew the place. Jaissle’s dressing room has players who have spent years in this league, Joelinton and Dan Burn among them. They can tell him where the Premier League punishes a high line or a vacated channel, and a head coach who takes that advice early will adapt faster than one who has to learn it on Saturdays.

    Patience should still come with conditions. Here is what I would hold him to over the next few games. Does Newcastle’s press come in spells, with calmer periods in between? And is it clear who picks up the crosser when the full-backs are high? If both improve, Jaissle is adapting, even if the results take longer to follow. Crystal Palace away on Saturday 24 October, Everton at home a week later and Arsenal on 21 November give him three tests of it.

    So I’d ask supporters to hold their nerve. After two 4-1 defeats and a home loss, they booed the team in frustration, and nobody can say they had no reason. But the boos fix nothing. The squad is fixed until January, so the only thing that can improve over the next few weeks is how Jaissle and the players work together, and that needs training days and match minutes. Turning on the head coach now would restart the same learning with someone else, who would inherit the same midfield, the same legs and the same absences. Managers who have become great were each given time to reshape a squad, and none of them could have done it in a month.

    Newcastle sit eleventh on eight points. Back the team at Selhurst Park on Saturday, and judge Jaissle on whether it looks like a side that is learning.