Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Cup first: why Jaissle should send his best side to Everton on Thursday

by


Everton v Newcastle Cup

Newcastle meet Everton in the Carabao Cup on Thursday and in the Premier League on Monday, and Matthias Jaissle has the squad to spend his strongest players on the first.

Malick Thiaw scored inside a minute on Newcastle’s last visit to the Hill Dickinson Stadium, and it was 3-0 by half-time.

That was 29 November. Lewis Miley made it 2-0 on 25 minutes, Nick Woltemade made it 3-0 on 45, and Thiaw added a fourth after the break. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Everton’s attacking midfielder, found a consolation on 69. Eddie Howe picked that team and stepped down in July after nearly five years. Woltemade is on loan at Juventus. Miley sat out Sunday’s win at Crystal Palace with a glute injury. Thiaw is expected to start on Thursday.

The ground sits on Bramley-Moore Dock, on the Mersey waterfront, with room for roughly 52,700. Newcastle have 7,732 of those seats, about one in seven, at £20 an adult and handed out in order of loyalty points. Kick-off is 7.45pm, under floodlights, on a late-October night beside the river.

Two games, one opponent

Four days after the Cup tie, Everton are at St James’ Park for the league. Jaissle has to pick two teams for the same opponent, and whatever he does on Thursday shapes Monday.

He is three months into the job and the first eight league games have drawn criticism. Newcastle are eighth on 11 points from eight games, with a goal difference of minus two, a total that includes 4-1 defeats at Leeds United and Coventry City and a 1-0 home loss to Aston Villa. Jaissle spent last week defending his tactics in public. Then came Selhurst Park: Will Osula scored just after the break, Harvey Barnes on 58 minutes, and Newcastle had a first win there in six years and a first clean sheet since August.

David Moyes, 63, has a week of his own to repair. Everton went unbeaten through their first six league games, then lost 2-0 at home to Chelsea and 2-0 at Arsenal without scoring in either. They are 11th on ten points, with two wins from four league games at home and goals hard to find. Three of the eighteen outfield players on their senior list are doubtful: Jarrad Branthwaite, the centre-back, with concussion, left-back Vitaliy Mykolenko with a knock, and winger Jack Grealish with an illness. Thierno Barry, a 24-year-old French centre-forward, is the only out-and-out striker on that list.

The history is thin on comfort for Newcastle. Howe went four league games without a win against Everton from December 2023, starting with a 3-0 defeat at Goodison Park, and the 4-1 last November was the first victory of the run. Moyes, back at Everton since January 2025, has beaten Newcastle twice in three meetings.

A first test against the old hand

Jaissle was born in April 1988, when Moyes was a 24-year-old centre-back at Shrewsbury Town. Moyes took his first job in management, at Preston North End, in January 1998, when Jaissle was nine. He was appointed at Everton in March 2002, at 38, which is Jaissle’s age now, and his first Premier League match as a manager came against Fulham on 16 March that year. In January 2025 he became only the third man to manage 700 Premier League matches, after Arsène Wenger and Sir Alex Ferguson.

Newcastle is Jaissle’s first job in English football. He was an assistant at Brøndby in Denmark, then a head coach at Salzburg in Austria and Al-Ahli in Saudi Arabia, and Thursday is his 11th competitive match with Newcastle. Moyes managed Everton alone for 518 games in his first spell.

The gulf in experience is huge. The next two games will show whether it matters.

The case for Thursday

My view is that Jaissle should put his best eleven on the pitch at Everton and deal with Monday afterwards. On Tuesday he said he would go “all in” for the Cup and that supporters should expect “not too many changes”.

The Cup is the one competition where Newcastle have a recent record to protect. A final in 2023, a quarter-final in 2024, the 2025 trophy that ended 70 years without a major domestic honour, a semi-final against Manchester City last winter. A last-eight place this season would be the fifth in a row. Howe won it. Jaissle arrives with two AFC Champions League titles from Al-Ahli, and a first trophy on Tyneside would settle a good many of the questions asked in October. Newcastle reached this round by beating West Bromwich Albion 3-2 and Millwall 1-0, and Everton by beating Preston North End 4-0 and Wolverhampton Wanderers 1-0.

The squad numbers favour him. Newcastle spent about £265m on eight senior signings this summer, before add-ons, and a squad that size is there to be used. Moyes cannot do the same. With as few as fifteen fit outfield players he will pick largely the same group on Monday as on Thursday, whatever he does with the Cup side. If Moyes goes strong on Thursday, those players get four days before the trip north, and if he rotates, Newcastle’s best eleven meets an Everton side below full strength.

Four days is ordinary recovery in the Premier League, so no one should promise tired legs on Monday. What Newcastle hold is a choice that Moyes mostly lacks.

Extra time is the risk. Cup ties go to 120 minutes and then penalties, and a starting eleven that plays them all will feel it against Everton at the weekend. The bench decides those nights. Anthony Elanga and Jacob Ramsey are back from injury on managed minutes, and Bazoumana Touré and Aladji Bamba, the summer signings from Hoffenheim and Monaco, are waiting for minutes of their own.

The price on Monday is real. Everton have won their last two visits to St James’ Park, 1-0 on the final day of 2024-25 through Charly Alcaraz, an attacking midfielder who is still on their books, and 3-2 last February, when Barry struck on 83 minutes, seconds after Jacob Murphy had levelled. Jordan Pickford, England’s goalkeeper, kept it that way with a late save. Newcastle have won one of their last six league meetings with Everton.

Thursday’s eleven

In a 4-2-3-1: Horníček; Dedić, Botman, Thiaw, Hall; González, Joelinton; Murphy, Willock, Barnes; Osula.

Lukáš Horníček, the Czech goalkeeper signed from Braga for £25.7m, is expected to start both games, with Ewen Jaouen out until December. Amar Dedić, the Bosnian right-back from Benfica, has no natural cover while Tino Livramento is out, and Miley, the midfielder who steps in at right-back when needed, missed Sunday with a glute injury and is still a doubt. The centre-backs are the clearest call. Sven Botman and Thiaw are the first-choice pairing, started the Villa defeat and were rested at Selhurst Park, which leaves them fresh for a Cup night.

Osula leads the line on form. He scored on Sunday, and Yoane Wissa, who wore the armband at Millwall, was dropped for Palace after the Villa defeat. Joe Willock plays behind Osula. He turned in Lewis Hall’s cutback for the 81st-minute winner at The Den in the last round, moments after Millwall’s Taïryk Arconte had hit the post. Murphy keeps his wing, and Barnes, who scored on Sunday, takes the other. Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the £51m forward signed from Lille on deadline day, missed Sunday through illness and is still a doubt, which leaves out the extra pace Jaissle might want against full-backs Moyes may have to improvise.

Everton are likely to line up Pickford; Maitland-Niles, O’Brien, Tarkowski, Garner; Armstrong, Hackney; Dibling, Dewsbury-Hall, George; Barry. Ainsley Maitland-Niles, 29, would play at right-back and the veteran James Tarkowski, 33, would pair with Jake O’Brien, 25, in central defence. James Garner, a midfielder by trade, would play at left-back with Mykolenko doubtful. Hayden Hackney, a 24-year-old midfielder who breaks lines with the ball, and Harrison Armstrong, a 19-year-old, caught the eye at Murrayfield in pre-season, the only time Moyes and Jaissle have faced each other. Tyler Dibling and Tyrique George, both 20, would supply the width. Christian Nørgaard, the 32-year-old Danish midfielder, is still being eased back after a groin injury and is the player Moyes can bring on late to slow the game down.

Monday

In a 4-2-3-1: Horníček; Dedić, Schär, Burn, Hall; González, Joelinton; Touré, Ramsey, Elanga; Wissa.

This is the back four that kept the clean sheet at Palace. Fabian Schär and Dan Burn, both 34, played that game, with Burn captaining, and a Cup-first week gives them one start and eight days between games. Botman and Thiaw sit down. They will meet Dibling and George, both 20, at a pace the older pair would not choose, which is the cost of the plan. Hall on the left and the González and Joelinton pairing in front of them will have to cover the gap.

The front four come from Sunday’s bench. Touré, Ramsey, Elanga and Wissa have fresh legs and something to prove, and two of them are on managed minutes. If Ramsey or Elanga cannot start, Willock or Murphy stays in. Dedić plays again unless Livramento, listed as a knock with a return in early November, is back in time.

St James’ Park has produced two draws, a win and a defeat in the league this season, in front of an average crowd of about 52,600. Monday night, 2 November, is the fifth home league game, under the lights, against a side that has won there twice running.

Jaissle will have had Thursday’s result in hand for four days by then. A win in Liverpool would put Newcastle into the last eight for the fifth year running, where an away match against giant-killers, Fleetwood Town awaits.

You may also enjoy:

Club Davies Finance Jaissle Match Report Premier League Preview Rumours SCR Squad Strategy Tactics Transfers

Newcastle News