Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Two Managers Short of Time: Crystal Palace v Newcastle at Selhurst Park

by


Crystal Palace v Newcastle Match Poster

Two managers in their first Premier League seasons need a result at Selhurst Park on Sunday, and one of them has reportedly been given a deadline.

Crystal Palace v Newcastle United, Selhurst Park, Sunday 25 October, 2pm GMT.


Six minutes of stoppage time were left at St James’ Park last Saturday night when Dan Burn, all 6ft 7in of him, was sent up front as an emergency striker.

Newcastle were a goal down. Johan Manzambi, the Villa midfielder who had agreed to join the Magpies in the summer until Villa swooped, had headed in the winner in the 36th minute, and Newcastle’s only shot on target all evening had come from centre-half Sven Botman. The boos at half-time were saved for the final whistle. Matthias Jaissle pushed Yoane Wissa back into midfield and sent on Burn, the club captain, who had returned from injury at Coventry a few days earlier.

Villa held on.

Which manager is under more pressure?

Sunday arrives with both dugouts short of time. Pierre Sage has the clearer deadline: Sky Sports News reported this week that chairman Steve Parish has given him Thursday’s game in Istanbul and this one to improve results, particularly at the back, and that a change is likely if he doesn’t get it. A defeat would be Palace’s fifth in eight league games.

Jaissle’s position is quieter and harder to read. Reports on Tyneside say the board, led by chief executive David Hopkinson, still backs him, and he told his press conference that coaching Newcastle is “a privilege” and that he would use another word than pressure. The crowd at St James’ Park chose a different word on Saturday night. A defeat at Selhurst Park would be Newcastle’s fourth in five league games, and the table is tight enough to make the stakes plain: going into the weekend they were 11th on eight points, with Palace 14th on seven.

The two men have never faced each other, as far as the record shows, and each followed a hard act. Oliver Glasner won Palace’s first major trophy, the FA Cup, and Eddie Howe took Newcastle into the Champions League twice.

We haven’t won at Selhurst Park since 2020

Newcastle’s last visit to Selhurst Park ended in a late defeat. On 12 April, striker Will Osula, who is back in contention after injury, put Newcastle ahead in the 43rd minute. They led until the 80th, when substitute Jean-Philippe Mateta headed in an equaliser. In the fourth minute of stoppage time, after a long throw, Botman pulled the shirt of Palace midfielder Jefferson Lerma, and Mateta scored the penalty. The 2-1 defeat piled more pressure on Howe, who left in the summer.

Newcastle have not won at Selhurst Park since November 2020.

Sean Steur, the forgotten talent?

Sean Steur is 18, a Dutch playmaker signed from Ajax in the summer. He was man of the match in the 2-1 win over Hull before the international break, and Jaissle described his display as one you would expect from “a really experienced, mature, old player.” Then Nico González came back from concussion, and Steur dropped to the bench at Coventry and stayed there against Villa. Two defeats, no minutes. He is arguably the club’s best player this season, and the home supporters were bewildered when he stayed seated while Burn went up top. Jaissle says Steur is “knocking on the door” but needs time, and some predicted line-ups for Sunday have him starting.

Older heads, back from injury

It sits awkwardly beside the case Jaissle has been making for experience. The team behind that last-minute gamble was young: Lukáš Horníček 24, Lewis Miley 20, Malick Thiaw 25, Botman 26 and Lewis Hall 21, an average of just over 23. Burn, Fabian Schär and Nick Pope, all 34, began on the bench. Much of the experience left in the summer, with Bruno Guimarães going to Arsenal, Sandro Tonali to Tottenham and Anthony Gordon to Barcelona, and Jaissle told reporters on Friday that the older players now returning from injury have to fill that gap.

Joelinton, 30, is already back and wore the armband against Villa. Burn could start on Sunday. Anthony Elanga has trained all week but Jaissle says he cannot yet manage 90 minutes, and Jacob Ramsey, who hurt his thigh in the warm-up at Leeds, is only just back on the grass.

Players in unfamiliar places

How Jaissle arranges them will draw as much attention as who he picks. In recent games Wissa has been used at No 10 (as he was at Coventry), Joe Willock deeper as a six and Matias Fernandez-Pardo mostly at No 9, which critics say puts all three out of position. Miley is a midfielder who can cover at right-back when the situation demands it, and he has been filling in there with Tino Livramento out and Amar Dedić only recently fit. Dedić’s return gives Jaissle a natural alternative on that side.

A rough week for Sage

Sage’s own week has been rough. Palace were three goals down inside ten minutes at Brighton and lost 5-0, and he apologised to the fans. Thursday in Istanbul went better, up to a point: they scored twice in four minutes through Yéremy Pino and Mateta, and Besiktas equalised in the 73rd minute from their second shot on target. Next, Sage said, “we need to win against Newcastle.”

What the numbers say

The defending is where the questions sit. Palace have let in 17 league goals in seven matches, the most in the division, and five came inside the first 15 minutes. Newcastle have let in 14, level with Sunderland, and have gone 16 home matches without a clean sheet, a club record. Goals are another matter. Newcastle have scored ten, though Squawka’s expected-goals model rates their chances at 7.5, and they have not scored more than twice in a league game this season. Palace’s goals come in bursts, three against Fulham and three against Forest, with blanks at Everton, Leeds and Brighton. Forward Jørgen Strand Larsen is out with a knock, and Sage said Mateta looked tired by the end in Istanbul.

Score Prediction: 2-2

Over 2.5 goals has landed in five of seven league games for both clubs, so goals are a safe bet. Three for Newcastle is a bigger ask, since they have not managed it in the league all season. The prediction here is 2-2, and a draw would do little for either man. Palace have conceded first in each of their last four games in all competitions, which makes an early Newcastle goal the likeliest route to a first win at Selhurst Park in almost six years.

A win would take Newcastle to 11 points before Everton visit St James’ Park on Monday 2 November. Jaissle names his side about an hour before kick-off, and the two names to look for are Burn and Steur.

You may also enjoy:

Club Davies Finance Jaissle Match Report Premier League Preview Rumours SCR Squad Strategy Tactics Transfers

Newcastle News