Data Driven Insights. Fearless Opinions.

Squad

  • Newcastle 2, Crystal Palace 0: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

    Crystal Palace v Newcastle Match Review

    A first away league win since August, a first clean sheet since the same weekend, and a first half Matthias Jaissle’s side would rather forget.

    Three minutes in, Adam Wharton, Palace’s England midfielder, floated a free-kick into the Newcastle penalty area and the ball refused to leave. Axel Disasi, the French centre-half, swung at it twice and was blocked twice. Jean-Philippe Mateta, the French striker who scored twice against Newcastle on this ground in April, got two clean looks of his own. Lukáš Horníček, the 24-year-old Czech goalkeeper, kept out both.

    Four efforts inside a minute, worth a little over a goal by FotMob’s reckoning. Selhurst Park, 25,018 strong on a bright, mild Sunday, roared like a ground that believed its season was about to turn. Palace had lost 5-0 at Brighton a week earlier, and Pierre Sage, their head coach, needed something to hold. For twenty minutes he had it. By half-time his side had taken eight shots, and Newcastle four.

    Newcastle won 2-0 anyway. William Osula scored in the 47th minute and Harvey Barnes in the 58th, which gave Newcastle their first league win on the road since Tottenham on 29 August, and their first clean sheet since that same afternoon. Getting there needs sorting into the good, the bad and the ugly.

    THE GOOD

    Nico González finds his feet. For weeks he has looked like a player still arriving. On Sunday he arrived. The Spaniard held the middle of the pitch with a calm that spread outwards: unhurried on the ball, never still off it, and finished with eight recoveries and three dribbles attempted, all three completed. In the way he drifted into pockets and found the pass early, there were moments that recalled Bruno Guimarães.

    He is not quick. When a Palace attacker got past him in the first half, González grabbed what he could, took a yellow card on 36 minutes, and so collected his second booking in as many games after the one against Villa. That is the cost. The return is larger. Jaissle kept picking him through the Villa defeat and said on Friday that he was pleased with his progress, because a run of games was always the route to match fitness. This was the first proper payment on it, and he looks like a man with more to give.

    Burn’s return gives the back line a spine. Dan Burn came back as captain and the defence took his shape. Jaissle left out Sven Botman and Malick Thiaw for him and Fabian Schär, and Burn cleared seven times, five of them with his head. Palace put 17 shots towards the Newcastle goal. Four were on target, two of those in the third-minute scramble, and Horníček saved all four.

    Jaissle adjusts. He said he would change things after Villa and he did: five alterations, a 4-2-3-1 with González and Joelinton paired in front of the defence, and a game plan that dropped the approach behind the defeats at Coventry and against Villa. In both, the front line pushed up near the opposition box and the side stretched from back to front. At Selhurst Park Newcastle squeezed. FotMob’s touch locations put the gap between the defenders’ average position and the forwards’ at 18.5 metres, the tightest of Newcastle’s eight league games and well inside the 22 against Villa and 25.6 at Coventry. The attackers sat about seven metres deeper than in either of those matches, and the side was a little narrower than at any other point this season. Nearly half of Newcastle’s attacks, 49%, came down the left, the highest share of the eight games. Whether it is better football is another matter, but it is a response, and finding one after two defeats is the job.

    Newcastle’s touch maps for the win at Palace and the defeats at Villa, Coventry and Leeds. The bracket marks the distance between the average position of the defenders and the forwards. Source: FotMob touch locations.

    THE BAD

    The centre-halves. Schär and Burn are both 34. They organise well and win headers, and neither has been quick for years. Palace took three shots off the break, at 7, 12 and 85 minutes. None hurt Newcastle, and Palace were caught offside four times, which says the line stepped up and held. It is a gamble all the same, and Arsenal arrive at St James’ Park on 21 November level on points at the top with Manchester City, who follow on Boxing Day. A high line with those legs behind it will not get such an easy afternoon against either of them.

    Murphy and Willock were both poor. Each had one moment worth remembering and very little to put beside it.

    Jacob Murphy’s low, early cross put Newcastle ahead, and it was a lovely piece of work. For long stretches around it he was a spectator in the attack, touching the ball 32 times in 90 minutes, fewer than any other outfield starter bar Osula, and attempting only 14 passes all afternoon. He ran the right flank up and down and covered his full-back without complaint, and nobody doubts the engine. A winger on 14 passes is still not giving a team much.

    Joe Willock had his own moment: Joelinton’s through ball, a clean finish across Walter Benítez in the Palace goal, and a VAR flag for moving a fraction too early. Take that away and the afternoon was thin. He won four of 13 ground duels, completed one of five dribbles, made one tackle and one clearance, and finished with FotMob’s lowest rating of any Newcastle starter, 6.4. He gave little with the ball and little without it. Ramsey and Elanga, who replaced Willock and Barnes at 77, are only just back from injury. As the rest of the squad returns to fitness, the question is how Murphy and Willock fit in, and on this evidence their place may be the bench.

    THE UGLY

    The first half. It was grim. Newcastle managed four shots, every one blocked or off target. Palace, who had taken eight, were unlucky not to be ahead. The ball went sideways, then backwards, then nowhere. Had Mateta finished either of his early chances, Jaissle would have been standing at half-time with a plan in pieces.

    The second half. Something Jaissle said in the dressing room worked inside two minutes. Murphy crossed and Osula finished in the 47th. Willock’s goal went to VAR and came back offside in the 52nd. Barnes made it two in the 58th, finishing from Amar Dedić’s low cross from the overlap. Newcastle had two shots on target all afternoon and scored with both. It was the best half of away football they have played this season, and the competition is not stiff: Newcastle lost 4-1 at both Leeds and Coventry.

    Which raises an awkward question. Palace had played in Istanbul on Thursday night, a 2-2 draw with Beşiktaş in the Europa League, and kicked off roughly 64 hours after the final whistle there. Sage changed nobody. The eleven who started in Turkey were the eleven who started at Selhurst Park, and after the break they looked it. Did fatigue, physical and mental, work against them? Palace played Lyon, Brighton, Beşiktaş and Newcastle in 11 days and won none of the four. They know Thursday nights, having won the Conference League in May for the club’s first European trophy, but that run ended with Oliver Glasner leaving, and Sage may be inheriting a squad still carrying the load. Newcastle know the feeling. Their Champions League campaign last season ran alongside a league campaign that sat mid-table that autumn, and the league is usually where the cost of European football shows up. A 5-0 defeat at Brighton followed by a night in Istanbul is a lot to carry into Selhurst Park, and the second half looked as much like a mental collapse as a physical one.

    WHAT’S NEXT

    Newcastle’s next game is at Everton on Thursday (7.45pm) in the fourth round of the EFL Cup, with the same opponents due at St James’ Park for the league on Monday night. Expect David Moyes to set Everton up in a compact block, as they did in Saturday’s 2-0 defeat at Arsenal, where they defended well for long spells and were undone by a corner and a header. Thierno Barry, their centre-forward, won 11 duels in that game, so the centre-halves face an evening of physical work, and set pieces will matter, since that was where Palace hurt Newcastle in the opening minutes at Selhurst Park. On the line is a place in the last eight, and a first test of whether this tighter shape can create chances against a side that gives away little space.

    Palace are at Fulham in the same competition on Wednesday.

  • Give Jaissle Time

    Patience

    Newcastle have lost three of their first seven league games, and the boos have already started. Panic now would cost the club more than the defeats have.

    In the 36th minute against Aston Villa on 17 October, João Gomes, Villa’s Brazilian midfielder, finds space on the right and crosses. Johan Manzambi, the 20-year-old Swiss attacking midfielder Newcastle had agreed a £49m fee for in July before Villa went higher, heads it past Lukáš Horníček.

    Watch it back and every Newcastle player near the ball has a job. Harvey Barnes, on the left, keeps his eye on Matty Cash, Villa’s right-back, overlapping behind the play. Lewis Hall stays tight to a runner cutting inside. Closing down Gomes falls to the midfield, and Nico González gets there late. After 35 minutes of chasing the ball high up the pitch he looks like a man who has run out of air.

    It was not a one-off. In the third game of the season, Bournemouth had 13 first-half shots at St James’ Park and one match report spoke of a team running out of steam. Jaissle said much the same after beating Hull: the legs went late, with nine players missing. At Coventry, Newcastle had 67% of the ball and 19 shots to nine and conceded four. ‘We controlled many phases but it’s not enough,’ Jaissle told the BBC.

    The plan is clear. González, signed from Manchester City for a reported £50m, told NUFC TV that Jaissle ‘wants direct football, intense’, with the ball won back high the moment it is lost. The midfielders who could have run all day for that, Bruno Guimarães and Sandro Tonali, left in the summer. González is a passer, and a good one: on his debut at Tottenham he lifted a long ball inside the first minute that led to a clear chance. Analysts who charted the early games noted that he drops between his centre-backs in build-up, so he starts attacks from deep and is then expected to sprint out and shut down the winger when they break down. At Villa he was late doing the second job.


    That adds up to a job half done, and the people meant to finish it need the time to do it.

    I have watched this happen at work whenever a new boss arrives with a new strategy. The people were hired for the old plan, and the new plan doesn’t alter what they are good at. Nobody sensible expects them to change in a few weeks. González won’t become an elite presser in two months, and no amount of booing will speed it up. The sensible route is to build the game around what the squad does well today and plan the move towards Jaissle’s ideal over a longer period. Some players switch quickly. Joelinton arrived at Newcastle as a striker and became one of the best midfielders in the league. Most take far longer.

    Newcastle supporters need no lecture on this, because we lived it. Eddie Howe took over a club that was 19th in November 2021 and spent most of that season in the bottom three. We finished 11th, and the year after we were in the Champions League. The same story runs through the league. Pep Guardiola ended his first year at Manchester City third and without a trophy, then won the title with 100 points. Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool finished eighth in his first season and were champions four years later. Clubs that waited were rewarded for it.

    Why should Newcastle give him this time? Start with what he did at Al-Ahli. He took over a side that had only just been promoted and came close to being sacked early in the 2024-25 season. The club’s board resisted a knee-jerk reaction and backed him to turn it around, and Al-Ahli’s fans reportedly protested when the club weighed replacing him with Massimiliano Allegri that January. He survived, finished that campaign as champion of Asia, and won it again the year after. Along the way he rebuilt his own football. At Salzburg he ran a young, pressing-first side. At Al-Ahli he had to fit Riyad Mahrez, Roberto Firmino, Ivan Toney and Franck Kessié into a 4-2-3-1, with more weight on defensive organisation and quick counter-attacks down the flanks. A data review of his Saudi years found that Al-Ahli became less possession-heavy and less busy without the ball, and defended better anyway, because the press became more efficient. He kept his principles and changed the workload. That is the skill Newcastle need from him now, and he has already shown it under heavier pressure than a poor October. After Coventry he said the formation was not the issue. If he is right, the thing that has to flex is what he asks of the players inside it.

    The second reason is what the failures look like. Legs fading late, one midfielder carrying two jobs and nobody named to pick up the crosser are coaching problems, and coaching problems get fixed on a training ground. They don’t suggest a dressing room that has stopped listening. Five days after the 4-1 defeat at Leeds, Newcastle beat Hull 2-1 with goals in the third and seventh minutes, with nine players missing. At Coventry they had most of the ball and 19 shots. That is a squad that wants to do what it is told and is finding the limits of what it can do, which gives a good coach something to work with.

    I’d start with the press. A side that cannot sustain it for 90 minutes can still press well for 20, with spells in a mid-block when the legs go and the whole team resetting its shape together. It costs a little ambition and it protects the legs of a midfield that has not yet been built for the full 90.

    Then I’d give the wide channel an owner. When the full-backs push up in build-up, someone has to be named to pick up the crosser if the ball is lost, and the rule has to be drilled until nobody needs to think about it.

    González’s own job comes next. He does one of his two tasks far better than the other, and it is the one Jaissle bought him for. A midfield partner who covers ground would let him remain a passer.

    The last adjustment is about listening. Ted Lasso is a fictional American football coach who is suddenly hired, in the television series of the same name, to manage a Premier League club. He was an outsider learning an unfamiliar league in a hurry, and the useful part of that story was how he asked the people who already knew the place. Jaissle’s dressing room has players who have spent years in this league, Joelinton and Dan Burn among them. They can tell him where the Premier League punishes a high line or a vacated channel, and a head coach who takes that advice early will adapt faster than one who has to learn it on Saturdays.

    Patience should still come with conditions. Here is what I would hold him to over the next few games. Does Newcastle’s press come in spells, with calmer periods in between? And is it clear who picks up the crosser when the full-backs are high? If both improve, Jaissle is adapting, even if the results take longer to follow. Crystal Palace away on Saturday 24 October, Everton at home a week later and Arsenal on 21 November give him three tests of it.

    So I’d ask supporters to hold their nerve. After two 4-1 defeats and a home loss, they booed the team in frustration, and nobody can say they had no reason. But the boos fix nothing. The squad is fixed until January, so the only thing that can improve over the next few weeks is how Jaissle and the players work together, and that needs training days and match minutes. Turning on the head coach now would restart the same learning with someone else, who would inherit the same midfield, the same legs and the same absences. Managers who have become great were each given time to reshape a squad, and none of them could have done it in a month.

    Newcastle sit eleventh on eight points. Back the team at Selhurst Park on Saturday, and judge Jaissle on whether it looks like a side that is learning.

  • Newcastle 0-1 Aston Villa: one shot on target, and it came from a centre-half

    Match Report: Newcastle 0 Aston Villa 1

    Newcastle held the ball for most of a second half in which they never made a clear chance, and Villa’s single moment before the break was enough.

    On 36 minutes, João Gomes’s cross finds Johan Manzambi, and the Aston Villa midfielder rises to head in the only goal of the evening.

    Of course it is him.

    Manzambi, a Switzerland international, turned 21 on Wednesday and marked it with a goal in Villa’s 6-0 Champions League win over Fenerbahçe. In July he was Newcastle’s target: a £49m fee was reportedly agreed with Freiburg before he chose Villa instead, and Unai Emery’s club made him their record signing at a reported £59.5m. Now he scores again, in front of 52,626 people at St James’ Park, 93 short of a full house, on an 8°C evening. Emery will praise his “skills and intelligence” afterwards, and the physical work he does to help Villa defend.

    That goal decides the result; the evening around it falls into two halves that hardly resemble each other.

    Before the break

    Villa have the ball and keep it. They finish the half with 60% possession and 257 passes to Newcastle’s 168.

    Newcastle get the first shot away, a Harvey Barnes effort on seven minutes that is blocked. Two minutes later Villa break and Nicolas Jackson, their striker, shoots; Lukáš Horníček saves. On 18 minutes Joelinton is booked for a tackle on Manzambi and Sven Botman for a high, reckless challenge on Jackson. VAR checks Botman’s for serious foul play and leaves the yellow card standing. Jackson says afterwards that it was so high he nearly broke his leg; Sky Sports pundit Jamie Redknapp thinks it should have been red.

    Newcastle’s best spell comes from dead balls. Yoane Wissa heads a corner at goal on 23, shoots from another set piece on 26, and on 33 Botman heads a set piece at goal while Wissa shoots again in the same minute. Four attempts in ten minutes: three blocked, one off target, and together worth 0.14 expected goals (xG), the model’s measure of chance quality, where 1.0 would be a certain goal. A total that low means the chances keep arriving and almost none of them are likely to go in.

    Three minutes later, Villa score.

    Until then, the chance count is level enough: Newcastle have 0.21 xG from six shots, Villa 0.31 from four. Jaissle will call the opening half-hour a good one, and the numbers give him some support. He will also admit his side were shaky after the goal, and that it came too easily, with a man lost in the box and no pressure on the cross.

    Villa almost make it two before the break. Emiliano Buendía, Villa’s number 10, hits the post with a shot the model rates at just over one chance in five. Villa reach the interval with 0.90 xG from six shots; Newcastle with 0.21 from six, none on target. St James’ Park boos them off.

    After the break

    Emery moves first, sending on the Scotland midfielder John McGinn for Alysson Edward at the interval. Newcastle respond four minutes into the restart.

    On 49 minutes, Botman, the Dutch centre-half, shoots with his left foot from a set piece, and Zion Suzuki, Villa’s goalkeeper, gets his fingertips to it. It is the first Newcastle shot on target of the night. It is also the last. Newcastle fire nine more efforts, five blocked and four off target, and Suzuki is never asked to save another.

    From here Newcastle have the ball: 59% of it, 113 passes in Villa’s half to 62, 24 touches in Villa’s box to 18. Villa’s passing accuracy drops to 74%.

    Villa answer with bodies. They win 73% of the ground duels and make 17 tackles to Newcastle’s seven. Their clearances reach 24. In a half where Newcastle foul eight times and collect four yellow cards (Nico González on 53, Wissa on 55, William Osula on 78, Malick Thiaw on 86), Villa foul twice.

    On 56 minutes Matthias Jaissle sends on Bazoumana Touré and Osula for Matias Fernandez-Pardo and Joseph Willock. A flurry follows nine minutes later. Wissa heads off target on 65. Osula, ten minutes into his night, does the same a minute later. On 69, Barnes and Wissa both shoot and both are blocked. Four attempts in five minutes, and Suzuki barely moves.

    Emery’s reply on 72 is three changes at once: Ibrahim Mbaye, a young forward, Ross Barkley and Germany midfielder Leon Goretzka replace Manzambi, Gomes and Buendía. Villa’s best moments now come on the counter. Jackson shoots on 73. Barkley follows a minute later and forces Horníček into a save. Villa finish the half with 0.67 xG from nine shots, four of them on the break.

    Newcastle’s two best chances come in consecutive minutes. On 84, Barnes, who has ten goal involvements in 13 Premier League games against Villa, shoots from open play and is blocked. The data rates it at 0.16 xG, the biggest chance Newcastle create all night, roughly one in six. On 85, a Newcastle break ends with Wissa shooting off target (0.13).

    Neither forces Suzuki into a save.

    At 90 minutes Jaissle replaces Joelinton with Daniel Burn, at 201cm the tallest man in the squad, and sends the centre-half up front. It is a tactical approach for the added time, Jaissle will explain, an all-out push. Burn, he adds, is still regaining fitness after a long spell out, and he hopes to see him back in his natural position soon. Six minutes are added. González shoots on 90+1 and again on 90+5, and both are blocked. The last act of the match is a shot worth 0.02 xG.

    The final whistle brings a second round of boos. Jaissle says afterwards that supporters are entitled to them: they come hoping to celebrate, and the team could not give them that.

    Wissa finishes with seven shots and none on target; the only Newcastle effort to reach Suzuki belongs to a defender. Newcastle win 26 aerial duels to Villa’s seven and hold the ball and the territory for most of the second half, yet they never make a clear chance. Their 16 shots carry 0.99 xG between them, Villa’s 15 carry 1.57, and Villa create three big chances to Newcastle’s none. It is hard to call that a robbery.

    Jaissle’s own verdict, to Sky Sports, is that his side dominated and controlled the game without being in Villa’s box often enough. The flaw, he says, was that Newcastle were “not smart enough in our decision making in the final third”. Afterwards he adds that he cannot fault the attitude: “the goal is missing”.

    Reading the effort

    Effort is the easiest thing at a football match to see and the hardest to price. On Saturday the numbers back what the eye says: Newcastle cover 118.4km, their most in any league game this season, make 134 sprints to Villa’s 120, and win 26 aerial duels to seven. Jaissle says his half-time message was about belief, and the second half looks like a team that heard it: the xG climbs from 0.21 to 0.78. His changes are visible too, the double substitution on 56 and Burn sent forward at the end, though the two players introduced on 56 add only 0.11 xG between them, and Emery has five substitutions to draw on against Jaissle’s three.

    The boos at half-time and full-time felt harsh. The effort was plain to see from every seat in the ground, and a young squad still finding its way needs the supporters behind it.

    The season so far shows the same pattern. Newcastle’s running is level with their opponents’ (more distance in four of seven league games, more sprints in four), yet their expected goals have beaten the opposition’s only once, at Coventry, where they lost 4-1. Results have swung around the numbers: a 2-0 win at Tottenham on 0.72 xG to 1.12, a 4-1 defeat at Coventry on 1.84 to 1.47. Across the seven games, the 10 goals scored and 14 conceded each sit about two above the 8.2 xG created and 12.1 faced. The effort is there, and the shortfall sits in the final third, which is where Jaissle places it too.

    What comes next

    Seven league games in, Newcastle have two wins, two draws and three defeats, with 10 goals scored and 14 conceded, and for the first time this season they leave a league match without a goal. They sit 11th, level on eight points with Villa in 12th. The back line that shipped eight across the trips to Leeds and Coventry gave up one here, although that one extends a club-record run of 16 games without a clean sheet in all competitions, according to Sky Sports. The defensive step forward gives a young squad something to hold onto while it learns Jaissle’s methods. Finding the target is the next job.

    Selhurst Park comes first, against Crystal Palace next Sunday, then Everton at St James’ Park on Monday 2 November and Fulham away five days after that. FotMob lists Jacob Ramsey (thigh) for a late-October return, Anthony Elanga (knock) as a mid-October absentee, and Tino Livramento (knock) for early November, so help may arrive in the window between those fixtures. The Tyne-Wear derby against Sunderland at St James’ Park follows on 5 December.

    Villa arrived on the back of a 6-0 Champions League win over Fenerbahçe on Wednesday and a league record of 11 goals conceded in six games, their most at that stage since 1986-87. They leave with clean sheets on Wednesday and Saturday, and Viking next in the Champions League in midweek. Emery says the league remains Villa’s priority, and that keeping clean sheets is what they have been working on.

    At Selhurst Park next Sunday, a forward testing the goalkeeper would be a start.

  • The Wednesday Villa and the Saturday Villa

    Newcastle v Aston Villa Preview

    Newcastle’s reply to Coventry meets Unai Emery’s tired legs at St James’ Park

    Newcastle United v Aston Villa | Premier League | St James’ Park | Saturday 17 October, 5.30pm (UK)

    Seconds before Coventry’s third goal on Monday night, Joelinton collects the ball inside his own penalty area and tries to dribble out of trouble.

    He has been on the pitch for barely twenty minutes. It is his first appearance of the season after injury. Brandon Thomas-Asante closes him down, the ball breaks to Ellis Simms, and a shot that takes a deflection off Malick Thiaw makes it 3-1.

    Five days later, Matthias Jaissle is hinting that the same man could start against Aston Villa. Dan Burn, the club captain, will most likely be too soon, the head coach said; Joelinton’s case, he implied, is different. Behind the hint sits a simple admission: “We missed them so much.”

    That one passage of play says a lot about Monday, and about this fixture. Newcastle had 67 per cent of the ball that night, 19 shots to Coventry’s nine, and six on target, exactly as many as the hosts. They still lost 4-1. Goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek’s spill handed over a sixth-minute penalty. Thiaw’s header only half-cleared the throw that dropped to Sidiki Cherif for the second. Then came the dribble. Jaissle called it “too many individual mistakes”, and the numbers back him: Newcastle ran the game for long spells and gave it away in a handful of seconds.

    The steel question

    “Steel” is football shorthand for resilience: how a side reacts after a heavy defeat, and whether it can hold its shape and its concentration when a game turns against it. After Coventry, that is the question hanging over Jaissle’s players.

    St James’ Park is where Newcastle get to answer, and the home record gives them something to hold. They are unbeaten in five there (three wins, two draws), the latest a 2-1 win over Hull City before the international break.

    One thing keeps recurring, though. Newcastle have gone 12 Premier League home games without a clean sheet. A thirteenth would equal the club record, set between December 1998 and August 1999 under Ruud Gullit. They have conceded 13 goals in six league games, joint-most in the division, and their one shutout came in a 2-0 win at Tottenham at the end of August.

    Newcastle have also scored in every league game this season, ten goals in six. Anthony Elanga, Tino Livramento and Jacob Ramsey remain out. Burn has trained only a couple of times since his return. Jaissle has said openly that he is building as the season runs. There will be ups and downs, he said this week, and he expects “one of those seasons”.

    The question on Saturday is narrow. Can eleven players go ninety minutes without handing over a goal? Jaissle leans on the crowd for the answer. At home, he said, “we can hurt every opponent”.

    The Wednesday Villa

    Villa arrive from a record night. The 6-0 win over Fenerbahce was their biggest European win and the biggest victory in any competition under Emery. Nicolas Jackson, the Senegalese striker, and Ross Barkley, the midfielder, scored two apiece. Jackson has four goals in his last three appearances.

    Jaissle knows what that does to a dressing room. It gives them “a huge boost”, he said, before pointing out that Villa have problems of their own in the league.

    They do. Villa sit 16th with five points from six matches, five points behind the top four, where they finished last season. They have lost 4-0 at Brighton, and at home to both Arsenal and Nottingham Forest. Wednesday was their first home win of the season in any competition, and Emery’s own words afterwards drew a line between two worlds: the Champions League, he said, is “the competition where we can feel comfortable”.

    So does momentum carry over? Only partly. The Wednesday Villa and the Saturday Villa have looked like different teams, and the Saturday version has been better away from Villa Park than at it. Since the opening-weekend defeat at Brighton, they have won three and drawn one of their last four away games in all competitions, including at Tottenham and Coventry. A trip north does not frighten them.

    Three days against five

    What might is the calendar. Newcastle have had nearly five days since Coventry. Villa have had roughly three since Wednesday night.

    Emery addressed it on Friday. “Some players may be tired,” he said, adding that he meant soreness rather than injury. He said “the rotation is coming” when his players are ready for his demands, but he would not name his XI until after training, and he wants players at full capacity, not 80 per cent.

    The clues sit in the predicted team. Leon Goretzka, the summer signing, made his first appearance on Wednesday as a substitute and may not yet be ready to start. Joao Gomes and Boubacar Kamara, both midfielders, could return to the middle, with Emiliano Buendia, the playmaker, in for the scoring Barkley. At left-back, with Ian Maatsen and Matteo Ruggeri both injured, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, a right-back by trade, may fill in again. Midfielder Amadou Onana is also out.

    That would put him opposite Jacob Murphy, who appears on the right in the predicted Newcastle XI. It is a prediction, and Emery has until the team sheet to change it.

    Emery spoke respectfully of the opposition. He noted that Bruno Guimaraes and Sandro Tonali had left, that Nico Gonzalez has the quality to replace them, and that Newcastle have had more injuries than usual. Then he described what he expects at St James’ Park: pressing, duels, a crowd pushing the home side on. He wants fresh legs on his bench.

    Both managers are reshaping their squads. The Mag, the independent Newcastle publication, framed it as two clubs squeezed by financial rules and forced into selling key players and replacing them with younger, cheaper options. Emery’s version was gentler: he is building a team the way he has in previous seasons, but this time with new and young players trying to close the gap as quickly as possible.

    What to watch

    Start with Joelinton. If he plays, Jaissle gets experience in midfield, and the vice-captain, who would likely wear the armband with Burn not ready, gets an immediate chance to turn Monday’s memory into something better.

    Matias Fernandez-Pardo, the young forward, is next. Jaissle says he is already creating chances and is a goal away from getting his confidence back. He and Joe Willock both missed clear chances at Coventry.

    Then there is the opening quarter of an hour. At Coventry the penalty arrived in the sixth minute and Newcastle spent the rest of the night chasing. A calm start would tell Jaissle more than any statistic.

    The verdict

    History is mixed. Villa won 2-0 at St James’ Park in January and could now win there in consecutive top-flight visits for the first time. Newcastle won the FA Cup tie at Villa Park 3-1 a month later. Emery, meanwhile, is a win away from his 100th in the Premier League.

    Villa’s tired legs should show, if they show at all, in the last half hour. Newcastle’s response ought to be visible in their effort and shape, though a clean sheet is a bigger ask. Whichever side makes fewer mistakes probably wins it, and both can score: Newcastle have found the net in every league game, and Villa have a striker in form.

    Prediction: Newcastle 2-2 Aston Villa.

    A draw like that would carry its own footnote: a thirteenth home game without a clean sheet, and Newcastle level with Gullit’s side.

  • Coventry 4-1 Newcastle: The ball was ours, the moments were theirs

    Coventry 4 Newcastle 1 Match Report

    Newcastle had 67% of the possession and 19 shots at the Coventry Building Society Arena. They also made four mistakes, and Coventry punished every one.

    Lukas Hornicek has the ball. Then he doesn’t.

    Six minutes into a Monday night in Coventry, with 30,811 inside the arena, a routine ball drops out of his hands and runs loose. Sidiki Cherif, the Coventry striker making his first Premier League start, goes down. The referee points to the spot. Jack Rudoni, their attacking midfielder, steps up and scores.

    It is the kind of ball a Premier League goalkeeper collects without thinking. Hornicek should have held it the first time. FotMob’s rating for him, 4.8, was the lowest of anyone on the pitch.

    Everything Newcastle do for the rest of the night is an answer to that moment. Most of the answers are wrong.

    First half: all the ball, no goals

    And yet the ball is theirs. Newcastle push Coventry back, and the home side survive on two clearances from Bobby Thomas, a centre-back who spends the half throwing himself into the way of things.

    The first comes in front of an unguarded net, after Jacob Murphy knocks Harvey Barnes’ cross back into the danger area. The second is worse for Newcastle. Matias Fernandez-Pardo rounds Carl Rushworth, Coventry’s goalkeeper, with the goal in front of him, and Thomas gets back to clear that too.

    Credit to Thomas. But the second one is Pardo’s to finish.

    Newcastle paid a reported £51.4m to Lille for him on 1 September, and six weeks later he is still waiting for his first goal for the club. The numbers say he was involved: FotMob gave him 0.70 in combined expected goals and assists, the highest of any Newcastle player. That is the point. Involvement is what a decent forward provides. A £51m forward is paid for goals, and on a night when others are making mistakes at the back, Newcastle need him to cover for them at the other end. He is 21 and still settling, and there is time. That chance, though, is the sort he is expected to take.

    Newcastle go in a goal down.

    48 minutes: the throw

    Three minutes after the break, a long throw. Coventry have been firing them in all night.

    The clearance does not clear. Cherif takes a touch on the edge of the D, turns, and drills the ball into the bottom-right corner. 2-0.

    It is a lovely finish, and it is a goal Newcastle gift him. Yoane Wissa, the nearest man, is a beat slow to close him down. Joe Willock is off the pitch receiving treatment, which leaves Newcastle a man short as the throw comes in. That explains the shape of the defending. It does not excuse the reaction.

    Minutes later Sven Botman botches a clearance of his own and Cherif, with a second goal there for the taking, slices it wide. Newcastle have not earned the reprieve.

    59 and 70 minutes: the door opens

    Matthias Jaissle reaches for his bench. Amar Dedić, Joelinton and Bazoumana Touré come on for Lewis Miley, Willock and Murphy, and the game tilts. Dedić looks sharper at right-back than Miley had before him.

    Eleven minutes later Botman drives a 20-yard shot into the near corner, set up by Nico González. 2-1. The door is open.

    Newcastle never get through it.

    81 minutes: the touch

    Joelinton is 22 minutes into his first appearance of the season, after an injury that had kept him out of the opening seven matches. He takes a touch on the edge of his own area, and the ball gets away from him.

    Coventry pounce. Ellis Simms, a substitute striker who has been on the pitch for three minutes and 15 seconds, shoots, and it beats Hornicek. 3-1.

    One loose touch on the edge of his own area, and Coventry turn it into a goal. The fault is Joelinton’s. Match fitness explains the touch; it does not soften it.

    86 minutes: the glide

    Five minutes later it is four.

    Stephen Mfuni, a defender by trade on loan from Manchester City, has been on the pitch for three minutes and 31 seconds. He glides past Newcastle’s players and into the penalty area, then finishes in off the far post, beyond Hornicek’s reach. Jay Dasilva, Coventry’s left-back, gets the assist.

    It is a fine piece of skill and Mfuni deserves the credit. But a substitute walking into the box that easily says more about where Newcastle’s heads are at 3-1 than it does about him.

    Twice on a Monday

    Leeds on 14 September. Coventry on 12 October. Two Monday-night away games, two 4-1 defeats. In between came a 2-1 win over Hull on 19 September and an international break that should have let the side carry that momentum forward. Once is a bad night. Twice, on the same night of the week and with the same ending, becomes a question.

    Newcastle are 11th with eight points, and the 13 goals they have conceded are the joint-most in the league, level with Chelsea and Bournemouth.

    What links Elland Road and Coventry

    On the surface the two nights look identical: Monday, away from home, 4-1. Underneath they are different matches, and it matters which problem belongs to which.

    Leeds was a beating on the pitch. Daniel Farke’s side had 14 shots to Newcastle’s seven and won the expected-goals count 1.99 to 0.88. Nico González had gone off inside 20 minutes as a concussion substitute, leaving 18-year-old Sean Steur and 20-year-old Lewis Miley as the midfield pair, and Miley’s deflection opened the scoring. Jaissle said afterwards that Newcastle could not match Leeds’ physicality in the first half. Coventry was the reverse. Newcastle were ahead on expected goals, faced only nine shots, and Coventry’s non-penalty xG was 0.64. At Leeds they were outplayed. At Coventry they beat themselves.

    Three threads run through both.

    The first is the long throw. Leeds’ fourth goal came in the 59th minute, when Newcastle failed to clear a long throw and Noah Okafor, a Leeds forward, volleyed in from the edge of the box. Coventry’s second, in the 48th, came from the same failure, with Cherif taking a touch on the edge of the D. It was not clear whether Newcastle were marking zonally or man for man. It was clear that nobody had Cherif. Whatever the scheme, the second ball dropped to a shooter on the edge of the area both times.

    The second is what happens next. Leeds scored three times in 14 minutes, Coventry twice in five. Newcastle do not just concede; they concede in clusters.

    The third is the personnel. Hornicek, Thiaw, Botman and Hall started both games, with Amar Dedić at right-back at Leeds and Miley at Coventry, and the unit has shipped eight goals in two away matches. That does not make them the whole problem. Botman made 17 defensive contributions at Leeds, more than anyone on the pitch, which says as much about the work the structure handed him as about him.

    Is it Jaissle’s system? Partly. Going into Leeds, Newcastle had faced more shots than any side in the league, averaging 20.3 a game, which suggests the press, built to win the ball high up the pitch, was being bypassed too easily and leaving the back four exposed. At Leeds that cost them. At Coventry it did not. The problem there was execution, not structure.

    Three adjustments suggest themselves. Put a body on the edge of the box for opposition long throws, so the second ball has an owner. Keep a midfielder deeper to cover behind the press when it is beaten; with González and Joelinton available again, Jaissle has the options. And when Newcastle are chasing a game, make sure a lost ball in midfield cannot become a shot on goal, because that is exactly how the 81st-minute goal arrived.

    None of that requires tearing up a system that has shown it can win matches. It requires finishing the job at the edges of the box.

    The good news is on the bench

    At Coventry, Newcastle were not outplayed. They created enough to win and wasted it: three big chances, all missed, and six shots on target worth a combined 0.39 in expected goals on target, against 2.63 for Coventry’s six. That is a finishing and decision-making problem, not a talent one, and those are the problems a squad can fix.

    And the squad is getting bigger. Newcastle’s bench at Coventry read Pope, Schär, Joelinton, Bamba, Osula, Steur, Touré, Burn and Dedić. Five of the nine players who missed the Hull win were back: González, back from concussion protocols, started, while Joelinton, Dedić, Will Osula and Dan Burn all came off the bench for minutes. Joelinton, mistake and all, brought the snap in the tackle that Newcastle’s midfield has been missing, and FotMob credited him with five defensive contributions in his 31 minutes.

    Four are still out: Tino Livramento, Jacob Ramsey, Anthony Elanga and goalkeeper Ewen Jaouen. Jaissle is rebuilding after the summer departures of Anthony Gordon, Bruno Guimarães and Sandro Tonali, and he has described it as a period of huge transition. The depth that was missing in the opening weeks of the season is returning.

    Saturday

    Aston Villa arrive at St James’ Park on Saturday, kick-off 5.30pm, sitting 16th on five points to Newcastle’s eight. The returnees will have a few more days of training behind them, and Joelinton, Dedić, Osula and Burn now carry minutes into the week.

    Coventry, on back-to-back league wins after their victory at Nottingham Forest before the break, travel to Tottenham, who have yet to win this season.

    Newcastle had 67% of the ball on Monday night and could not hold on to the things that mattered. Hornicek had it in his hands in the sixth minute and let it go. Against Villa, the chance is to start holding on.